The Problem of Policy Implementation: The case of performance appraisal

Authors:
  • HTHelen S. Timperley
    Helen S. Timperley
  • VRViviane M. J. Robinson
    Viviane M. J. Robinson

Abstract
National policy initiatives frequently suffer from slow and sporadic implementation, with requirements for school staff to be appraised being no exception. In this paper we identify how policy implementation might be improved if policy formulation was informed by a more detailed understanding of the local conditions which policy is designed to influence. We base our argument on a conceptualisation of policy as a response to a set of frequently conflicting local and national requirements. This conceptualisation, based on Nickles' constraint inclusion account of a problem, informed our case study of the implementation of the national performance management policy in one New Zealand high school. We discuss how the school's professional norms and beliefs about authority and the culture of conflict avoidance precluded effective implementation of the national policy mandate. An intervention that more closely aligned school cultural norms with national policy requirements involved negotiating a new set of constraints and appraisal practices with staff. We argue that national policy is more likely to be implemented if the process of policy formulation involves an ongoing dialogue about the adequacy and congruence of the beliefs and practices that inform both the proposed policy and the local practices that such policy is designed to implement.