A plea for scientific integrity: a comment on the honeybee odometer controversy
- 10 October 2025
- journal article
- other
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Comparative Physiology A
- Vol. 211 (5-6) , 641-644
Abstract
In a non-peer-reviewed arXiv preprint Laura Luebbert and Lior Pachter made numerous criticisms of the work of Mandyam Srinivasan and colleagues, suggesting that there was evidence of data duplication and data manipulation in their work. These imputations were amplified in a news article and blog post in the journal Science and then made news in the mainstream media in several countries. This media activity took place before journals and institutions had the chance to conduct formal investigations that would have allowed Srinivasan and his colleagues a fair hearing, with input from independent experts. In addition, there was no time for the scientific community to evaluate Luebbert and Pachter’s work. In particular, they made some very critical comments based on statistical simulations, where they claimed that R2 values reported by Srinivasan and colleagues in six papers were “ridiculously high”. In this commentary, I show that their inability to reproduce high R2 values was due to major flaws in their simulation models. Luebbert and Pachter have never responded in detail to my criticisms, instead relying on the logical fallacies of argument from authority and ad hominem attacks.Keywords
This publication has 7 references indexed in Scilit:
- A plea for academic truthJournal of Comparative Physiology A, 2025
- A plea for academic decencyJournal of Comparative Physiology A, 2025
- Comment on Miscalibration of the Honeybee OdometerarXiv, 2024
- Dismantling Babel: creation of a universal calibration for honey bee waggle dance decodingAnimal Behaviour, 2019
- Incorporating variability in honey bee waggle dance decoding improves the mapping of communicated resource locationsJournal of Comparative Physiology A, 2013
- Honeybee Odometry: Performance in Varying Natural TerrainPLOS Biology, 2004
- Honeybee Navigation: Nature and Calibration of the "Odometer"Science, 2000