Since its creation, Net Promoter Score (NPS) has become a standard measurement of customer loyalty and business growth. However, independent research results have challenged that status yet without budging corporate beliefs. The blind eye to inconsistent outcomes is due in part NPS’ simplicity and uneven but hopeful measures of positive business impact, even as companies are in the dark about the factors that impact their score. Therefore, measuring 1605 US-based customers of US publicly traded companies, this study has found that NPS was positively and significantly correlated with financial performance. However, two other dimensions of customer experience, technical innovation (TI) and perceived usability (PU) outperformed NPS with stronger correlations demonstrating both the value of NPS but also perhaps the need to look beyond. In addition, TI and PU were also strongly correlated with NPS, offering insights into aspects of the customer experience, customer loyalty and business performance that companies can use to impact their NPS score, which they would otherwise not know.