Precedential constraint
Authors:
Open Access
- 21 June 2021
- conference paper
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM)
- p. 12-21
Abstract
Horty, Rigoni and Prakken have developed formal characterisations of precedential constraint based on dimensions and factors as introduced in HYPO and CATO. We discuss the relation between dimensions and factors and also describe the current models of precedential constraint based on factors, along with some criticisms of them. We argue that problems arise from ignoring the structure of legal cases that is provided by the notion of issues, and that seeing precedential constraint in terms of issues rather than whole cases provides a more effective approach and better reflects legal practice. The advantages of the issue based approach are illustrated with a concrete example. We then discuss how dimensions should be accommodated, suggesting that this is best done by seeing reasoning with legal cases as a two stage process: first factors are ascribed to cases and then factor based reasoning can be used to arrive at a decision. Thus precedential constraint can be described in terms of factors, dimensions being handled at the first stage. Both stages are constrained, in different ways, by precedents: we identify three types of precedent: framework precedents which structure cases into issues, preference precedents which resolve conflicts between opposing sets of factors within these issues, and ascription precedents which constrain the mapping from facts to factors.Keywords
This publication has 27 references indexed in Scilit:
- An improved factor based approach to precedential constraintArtificial Intelligence and Law, 2015
- On balanceArtificial Intelligence and Law, 2015
- A factor-based definition of precedential constraintArtificial Intelligence and Law, 2012
- Automatically classifying case texts and predicting outcomesArtificial Intelligence and Law, 2009
- DO PRECEDENTS CREATE RULES?Legal Theory, 2005
- A model of legal reasoning with cases incorporating theories and valuesArtificial Intelligence, 2003
- Predicting outcomes of case based legal arguments2003
- Arguments and cases: An inevitable intertwiningArtificial Intelligence and Law, 1992
- The British Nationality Act as a logic programCommunications of the ACM, 1986
- The Direct and Collateral Estoppel Effects of Alternative HoldingsThe University of Chicago Law Review, 1983