Groundwater governmentality: hegemony and technologies of resistance in Rajasthan's (India) groundwater governance
Author:
- Trevor BirkenholtzTBTrevor Birkenholtz
- 2 September 2009
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in The Geographical Journal
- Vol. 175 (3) , 208-220
Abstract
Globally, decentralisation has become the dominant paradigm for environmental governance. This paper explores the linkages between green governmentality approaches to subjectivity and Gramscian notions of hegemony to examine recent efforts in Rajasthan, India to decentralise groundwater governance through targeted formal regulations and outreach activities, such as water awareness campaigns (Jal Abhiyaan). The latter seeks to alter the beliefs and practices of farmers by institutionalising their support for state groundwater conservation efforts, including privatisation. The paper draws on household surveys and interviews with farmers and government agents to examine the relationship between the political economic motivations for and practices of state subject‐making and differential resistance to these efforts based on farmers’ multiple subject positions. Findings suggest, first, that the state is motivated through its monetary and advisory relationship with donor agencies, such as the World Bank. Through both outreach activities and coercion, it attempts to gain ‘consent’ for its proposals, which devolve state control rather than truly decentralising decision‐making, to make self‐conducting and willing subjects of specifically neoliberal groundwater conservation. But, second, these attempts are being resisted by some farmers through protests, informal discussions, non‐participation, and the collectivisation of access to groundwater and irrigation through irrigation partnerships. Third, resistance to these efforts, or support for them, is different between farmers based on their multiple subjectivities (caste, class and ecological conditions). The paper advances both our understanding of the processes of environmental subject‐making and of the devolution of environmental governance, by integrating the lessons from governmentality and Gramscian approaches to social power and subjectivity.Keywords
This publication has 31 references indexed in Scilit:
- Green governmentality: insights and opportunities in the study of nature's ruleProgress in Human Geography, 2007
- Changing Concepts of Articulation: Political Stakes in South Africa TodayReview of African Political Economy, 2007
- From Hegemony to Governmentality: Changing Conceptions of Power in Social HistoryJournal of Social History, 2006
- Challenges of forest governance in MadagascarThe Geographical Journal, 2005
- Dispossessing H2O: the contested terrain of water privatizationCapitalism Nature Socialism, 2005
- The last enclosure: resisting privatization of wildlife in the Western United StatesCapitalism Nature Socialism, 2005
- Groundwater socio-ecology and governance: a review of institutions and policies in selected countriesHydrogeology Journal, 2005
- Non-Governmental Organizations and Governmentality: ‘Consuming’ Biodiversity and Indigenous People in the PhilippinesPolitical Studies, 2002
- Multiplex livelihoods in rural Africa: recasting the terms and conditions of gainful employmentThe Journal of Modern African Studies, 2002
- ‘A fist is stronger than five fingers’: caste and dominance in rural north IndiaTransactions of the Institute of British Geographers, 2001