Ethical Dilemmas Faced by Military Health Personnel During High-Intensity Conflict: The Crucial Issue of Triage
Authors:
- Frédérique Gignoux-FromentFGFrédérique Gignoux-Froment
- Thibault MartinezTMThibault Martinez
- Jean DerelyJDJean Derely
- Jean TurcJTJean Turc
- Simon-Pierre CorcosteguiSCSimon-Pierre Corcostegui
- Clément DerkenneCDClément Derkenne
- Vincent PeigneVPVincent Peigne
- Marion TrousselardMTMarion Trousselard
- Angèle BazinABAngèle Bazin
- Antoine LamblinALAntoine Lamblin
- 7 May 2024
- journal article
- editorial
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Military Medicine
- Vol. 189 (9-10) , 234-238
Abstract
Russia’s invasion of Ukraine has triggered the biggest conflict in Europe since the Second World War. It has forced countries to prepare for engagement on a massive scale, namely, a high-intensity war between nation states. A potential massive influx of wounded personnel risks saturating logistical supply chains and requires changes to not only medical care but also a paradigm shift. In this context, the principle of distributive justice is key. The aim is to save as many lives as possible through triage, which consists in “doing the greatest good for the greatest number.” This idea is fundamental, as an emergency that has passed is no longer an emergency. However, international texts and treaties not only underline that the sole criterion for triage is clinical severity, but they also fail to take into account the patient’s status (civilian, friend, and foe). In a high-intensity warfare situation, these texts, and the medical-surgical triage criteria they provide are insufficient, as caregivers may be required to make decisions based on the status of the patient. The need to make such choices could cause psychological suffering among military caregivers, as individuals are recurrently faced with difficult ethical dilemmas. One way to prevent this happening is to provide predeployment training in wartime medical ethics. The latter would include both instruction in international humanitarian law and practical simulations of clinical situations where the person is faced with an ethical dilemma.Keywords
This publication has 9 references indexed in Scilit:
- Estimating conflict losses and reporting biasesProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2023
- Ethical challenges faced by French military doctors deployed in the Sahel (Operation Barkhane): a qualitative studyBMC Medical Ethics, 2021
- Managing mental health challenges faced by healthcare workers during covid-19 pandemicBMJ, 2020
- Five years of prolonged field care: prehospital challenges during recent French military operationsTransfusion, 2019
- Greater prevalence of post‐traumatic stress disorder and depression in deployed Canadian Armed Forces personnel at risk for moral injuryActa Psychiatrica Scandinavica, 2018
- Dual loyalties: Everyday ethical problems of registered nurses and physicians in combat zonesNursing Ethics, 2017
- ‘A band of brothers’—an exploration of the range of medical ethical issues faced by British senior military clinicians on deployment to Afghanistan: a qualitative studyJournal of the Royal Army Medical Corps, 2016
- Towards an ethical theory in disaster situationsMedicine, Health Care and Philosophy, 2014
- Ethical Concerns for Physicians Deployed to Operation Desert StormMilitary Medicine, 1994