Frequency and Negative Impact of Medical Student Mistreatment Based on Specialty Choice
Authors:
- Tamara K. OserTOTamara K. Oser
- Paul HaidetPHPaul Haidet
- Peter R. LewisPLPeter R. Lewis
- David T. MaugerDMDavid T. Mauger
- Dennis L. GingrichDGDennis L. Gingrich
- Shou Ling LeongSLShou Ling Leong
- 1 May 2014
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Academic Medicine
- Vol. 89 (5) , 755-761
Abstract
According to responses to the Association of American Medical Colleges' Medical School Graduation Questionnaire, 17% to 20% of medical students report mistreatment. This study examined the longitudinal nature of medical student mistreatment based on specialty choice. From 2003 to 2010, the authors surveyed all medical students at one institution at the end of their third year, assessing the frequency and impact of any mistreatment based on specialty choice. They analyzed quantitative data on the frequency, impact, sources, and trends over time and qualitative data from students' open-ended responses and compared data by specialty interest (primary care versus subspecialty). Of the 1,059 students sent the survey, 801 (76%) responded. Mistreatment based on specialty choice was common. The frequency and impact of such mistreatment were tightly correlated (Pearson r = 0.8, P < .001). The nature of mistreatment differed between students interested in primary care and those interested in a subspecialty, occurred more commonly on specific clerkships, and originated most often from resident physicians. Students perceived that teaching opportunities and evaluations were negatively affected by their specialty choice. An association was found between the theme of respect and students reconsidering their specialty choice. These patterns of mistreatment were stable over the study period, despite several professionalism initiatives. Mistreatment based on specialty choice is a distinct and common phenomenon perpetuated by faculty, residents, and peers. More research is needed to explore the potential hidden curriculum drivers of these findings and to develop interventions specifically targeting this type of mistreatment.Keywords
This publication has 26 references indexed in Scilit:
- Eradicating Medical Student MistreatmentAcademic Medicine, 2012
- Student Mistreatment in Medical School and Planning a Career in Academic MedicineTeaching and Learning in Medicine, 2011
- Medical Student Mistreatment Results in Symptoms of Posttraumatic StressAcademic Psychiatry, 2009
- Student Treatment on Clerkships Based on Their Specialty InterestsTeaching and Learning in Medicine, 2006
- Academic Medicine and the Search for Meaning and PurposeAcademic Medicine, 2002
- On the culture of student abuse in medical schoolAcademic Medicine, 1998
- A study of medical studentsʼ specialty-choice pathwaysAcademic Medicine, 1997
- Frequency and effect of negative comments (“badmouthing”) on medical studentsʼ career choicesAcademic Medicine, 1996
- Medical Student AbuseJAMA, 1990
- Medical Student Abuse1984