Comparison of the Estimation of Spatiotemporal Distribution of Groundwater Recharge using SWAT+ and WetSpass Hydrological Models: A case of the Gilgel Gibe Catchment, Ethiopia
Authors:
- Fayera Gudu TufaFTFayera Gudu Tufa
- Fekadu Fufa FeyessaFFFekadu Fufa Feyessa
- Adisu Befekadu KebedeAKAdisu Befekadu Kebede
- Beekan Gurmessa GudetaBGBeekan Gurmessa Gudeta
- Wagari Mosisa KitessaWKWagari Mosisa Kitessa
- Seifu Kebede DebelaSDSeifu Kebede Debela
- Alemu YenehunAYAlemu Yenehun
- Thomas HermansThomas Hermans
- Kristine WalraevensKristine Walraevens
Preprint
- 2 April 2026
- preprint
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Abstract
Groundwater recharge is a pivotal component of the water balance, governing aquifer resilience and flow dynamics. Although its estimation remains one of the most challenging tasks in hydrogeology, understanding its spatiotemporal distribution is essential for sustainable groundwater use and management. This study applies SWAT+ and WetSpass to quantify the spatiotemporal distribution of groundwater recharge in the Gilgel Gibe catchment, where groundwater demand is rapidly increasing, and compares their recharge estimates to evaluate model robustness. Both models were set up using 38 years (1986–2023) of hydrometeorological data from ground-based and satellite sources, along with a digital elevation model, land-use/land-cover map, and soil data. Calibration and validation against observed river flow produced performance indicators within acceptable ranges. SWAT+ estimates annual recharge between 206 and 414 mm, with an average of 310 mm. WetSpass produces spatially distributed annual recharge ranging from 0 mm for open water to 725 mm for vegetated areas, with a mean of 337 mm. WetSpass indicates that 302 mm (90%) of annual recharge occurs from April to October, whereas SWAT+ identifies a later recharge period from May to November, contributing 297 mm (96%). Although annual estimates are comparable, monthly values differ markedly because SWAT+ accounts for delayed deep percolation, while WetSpass treats recharge as an immediate monthly water-balance residual. The findings provide valuable insights for decision-makers developing groundwater management strategies and offer essential input for groundwater modelling.Keywords
This publication has 33 references indexed in Scilit:
- Assessment of water supply and demand in Gilgel Gibe watershed, southwest EthiopiaSustainable Water Resources Management, 2022
- Assessment of the spatial–temporal distribution of groundwater recharge in data-scarce large-scale African river basinEnvironmental Monitoring and Assessment, 2022
- Estimation of groundwater recharge using GIS-based WetSpass model for Birki watershed, the eastern zone of Tigray, Northern EthiopiaSustainable Water Resources Management, 2018
- Assessment of the impact of climate change on surface hydrological processes using SWAT: a case study of Omo-Gibe river basin, EthiopiaModeling Earth Systems and Environment, 2016
- Groundwater conceptualization and modeling using distributed SWAT-based recharge for the semi-arid agricultural Neishaboor plain, IranHydrogeology Journal, 2014
- An Initial Inventory and Indexation of Groundwater Mega-Depletion CasesWater Resources Management, 2012
- Estimation of groundwater recharge using water balance coupled with base-flow-record estimation and stable-base-flow analysisEnvironmental Geology, 2006
- Groundwater recharge and sustainability in the High Plains aquifer in Kansas, USAHydrogeology Journal, 2005
- How to construct recursive digital filters for baseflow separationHydrological Processes, 2004
- Recharge and groundwater models: an overviewHydrogeology Journal, 2002