How repeatable is the Environmental Impact Classification of Alien Taxa (EICAT)? Comparing independent global impact assessments of amphibians
Authors:
- Sabrina KumschickSKSabrina Kumschick
- G. John MeaseyGMG. John Measey
- Giovanni VimercatiGVGiovanni Vimercati
- F. Andre de VilliersFVF. Andre de Villiers
- Mohlamatsane M. MokhatlaMMMohlamatsane M. Mokhatla
- Sarah J. DaviesSDSarah J. Davies
- Corey J. ThorpCTCorey J. Thorp
- Alexander D. RebeloARAlexander D. Rebelo
- Tim M. BlackburnTBTim M. Blackburn
Open Access
- 19 March 2017
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Ecology and Evolution
- Vol. 7 (8) , 2661-2670
Abstract
The magnitude of impacts some alien species cause to native environments makes them targets for regulation and management. However, which species to target is not always clear, and comparisons of a wide variety of impacts are necessary. Impact scoring systems can aid management prioritization of alien species. For such tools to be objective, they need to be robust to assessor bias. Here, we assess the newly proposed Environmental Impact Classification for Alien Taxa (EICAT) used for amphibians and test how outcomes differ between assessors. Two independent assessments were made by Kraus (Annual Review of Ecology Evolution and Systematics, 46, 2015, 75‐97) and Kumschick et al. (Neobiota, 33, 2017, 53‐66), including independent literature searches for impact records. Most of the differences between these two classifications can be attributed to different literature search strategies used with only one‐third of the combined number of references shared between both studies. For the commonly assessed species, the classification of maximum impacts for most species is similar between assessors, but there are differences in the more detailed assessments. We clarify one specific issue resulting from different interpretations of EICAT, namely the practical interpretation and assigning of disease impacts in the absence of direct evidence of transmission from alien to native species. The differences between assessments outlined here cannot be attributed to features of the scheme. Reporting bias should be avoided by assessing all alien species rather than only the seemingly high‐impacting ones, which also improves the utility of the data for management and prioritization for future research. Furthermore, assessments of the same taxon by various assessors and a structured review process for assessments, as proposed by Hawkins et al. (Diversity and Distributions, 21, 2015, 1360), can ensure that biases can be avoided and all important literature is included.Keywords
Funding Information
- South African Department of Environmental Affairs through its funding of SANBI's Invasive Species Programme
- DST-NRF Centre of Excellence for Invasion Biology
- EU COST Action TD1209 Alien Challenge
This publication has 32 references indexed in Scilit:
- Application of the Environmental Impact Classification for Alien Taxa (EICAT) to a global assessment of alien bird impactsDiversity and Distributions, 2016
- Weed Risk Assessments Are an Effective Component of Invasion Risk ManagementInvasive Plant Science and Management, 2016
- History and recent progress on chytridiomycosis in amphibiansFungal Ecology, 2016
- Comparing determinants of alien bird impacts across two continents: implications for risk assessment and managementEcology and Evolution, 2014
- A Unified Classification of Alien Species Based on the Magnitude of their Environmental ImpactsPLOS Biology, 2014
- Phylogeographic patterns of genetic diversity in eastern Mediterranean water frogs were determined by geological processes and climate change in the Late CenozoicJournal of Biogeography, 2010
- Predicting plant invaders in the Mediterranean through a weed risk assessment systemBiological Invasions, 2009
- Origin of the parasites of an invading species, the Australian cane toad (Bufo marinus): are the lungworms Australian or American?Molecular Ecology, 2008
- The relationship between the emergence of Batrachochytrium dendrobatidis, the international trade in amphibians and introduced amphibian speciesFungal Biology Reviews, 2007
- The emerging amphibian pathogen Batrachochytrium dendrobatidis globally infects introduced populations of the North American bullfrog, Rana catesbeianaBiology Letters, 2006