Dimensions of Equity in the Science of Reading Research: A Systematic Review of Actual, Artificial, and Absent Up‐Takes of Equity
Open Access
- 18 October 2025
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Wiley in Reading Research Quarterly
- Vol. 60 (4)
Abstract
The Science of Reading (SoR) movement is positioned as a pathway to equity in literacy development, yet little is known about how equity is defined and enacted within SoR scholarship. This systematic review examined 36 peer‐reviewed studies published between 2014 and 2024 that addressed both SoR and equity. Using a framework of nine equity dimensions, we analyzed how equity was conceptualized and operationalized across this body of research. Findings reveal that only 17% of screened articles (36/211) engaged with equity dimensions in substantive ways. Analysis showed that equity was primarily conceptualized through access ( n = 69) and opportunity ( n = 83), with most studies giving limited attention to race, power structures, and the systems that uphold inequities. SoR research primarily focused on three student groups: emergent bilinguals, “struggling” readers without disabilities, and students from low socioeconomic backgrounds, while largely employing race‐evasive language such as “diverse” or “struggling students.” By contrast, actual uptakes of equity, though limited, were most often found in international contexts where inclusion and representation were embedded through culturally and linguistically responsive adaptations. These findings highlight a persistent disconnect between SoR's equity claims and its research base, underscoring the need to integrate transformative justice approaches so that equity efforts move beyond access and opportunity toward systemic change in literacy development.Keywords
This publication has 41 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Science of Reading Progresses: Communicating Advances Beyond the Simple View of ReadingReading Research Quarterly, 2021
- Advancing the Science of Teaching Reading EquitablyReading Research Quarterly, 2021
- Lost in Translation? Challenges in Connecting Reading Science and Educational PracticeReading Research Quarterly, 2020
- How the Science of Reading Informs 21st‐Century EducationReading Research Quarterly, 2020
- How the Reading for Understanding Initiative’s Research Complicates the Simple View of Reading Invoked in the Science of ReadingReading Research Quarterly, 2020
- The Simple View of Reading Made Complex by Morphological Decoding Fluency in Bilingual Fourth‐Grade Readers of EnglishReading Research Quarterly, 2019
- Literacy and Phonological Skills in Oral Deaf Children and Hearing Children With a History of DyslexiaReading Research Quarterly, 2019
- A Transformative Justice Approach to Literacy EducationJournal of Adolescent & Adult Literacy, 2018
- Academic Language as a Predictor of Reading Comprehension in Monolingual Spanish‐Speaking Readers: Evidence From Chilean Early AdolescentsReading Research Quarterly, 2017
- Lexical Quality Matters: Effects of Word Knowledge Instruction on the Language and Literacy Skills of Third- and Fourth-Grade Poor ReadersReading Research Quarterly, 2015