Analytical Comparison of Supply Chain Collaboration Levels Under Supply and Demand Uncertainty: Decentralized, Centralized, and Vendor-Managed Inventory
- 16 January 2026
- journal article
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management
- Vol. 73 (00189391) , 2094-2113
Abstract
This paper examines the impact of varying levels of buyer-supplier collaboration on supply chain (SC) performance under simultaneous demand and supply uncertainty. While collaboration is widely acknowledged as a lever for improving SC performance, prior analytical studies have predominantly focused on coordination mechanisms or contract structures. A gap persists in the literature regarding the quantified comparison of decentralized, partially collaborative, and fully collaborative policies-particularly under epistemic uncertainty, where limited data constrain the applicability of traditional probabilistic models. To address this gap, we develop an analytical model to evaluate three collaboration policies: (i) decentralized, (ii) joint economic lot-sizing (JELS), and (iii) vendor-managed inventory (VMI). The model integrates both demand- and supply-side uncertainty using general probability distributions. To capture epistemic uncertainty-common in pandemics, infrastructure disruptions, and other high-impact events-we adopt the PERT-Beta distribution, which is designed for expert-driven planning in data-scarce contexts. We derive closed-form expressions for expected SC surplus and identify conditions under which increasing collaboration improves system-wide performance. A surplus-sharing mechanism is introduced to equitably allocate collaborative gains across dyadic partners. Numerical simulations based on a healthcare case involving personal protective equipment (PPE) illustrate the theoretical findings and provide additional insights into the relative performance of the decentralized, JELS, and VMI policies under different parameter regimes and operating conditions. This study offers a tractable, generalizable model for analyzing SC collaboration under uncertainty and provides actionable insights for firms and policymakers seeking to strengthen SC performance, equity, and service levels during disruptions.Keywords
Funding Information
- Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada
This publication has 42 references indexed in Scilit:
- An analysis of the role of order quantity in supply chains with uncertainties from demand and/or supplyComputers & Industrial Engineering, 2023
- Dual‐channel supply chain coordination under risk aversion and fairness concernsManagerial and Decision Economics, 2023
- Coordinating a dual-channel supply chain with conditional value-at-risk under uncertainties of yield and demandComputers & Industrial Engineering, 2020
- Coordination for contract farming supply chain with stochastic yield and demand under CVaR criterionOperational Research, 2017
- Risk assessment and risk management: Review of recent advances on their foundationEuropean Journal of Operational Research, 2016
- Contracts and coordination: Supply chains with uncertain demand and supplyNaval Research Logistics (NRL), 2016
- Quality uncertainty and quality-compensation contract for supply chain coordinationEuropean Journal of Operational Research, 2013
- Revisiting the PERT mean and varianceEuropean Journal of Operational Research, 2011
- A Stackelberg game and its improvement in a VMI system with a manufacturing vendorEuropean Journal of Operational Research, 2009
- Coordination and profit sharing between a manufacturer and a buyer with target profit under credit optionEuropean Journal of Operational Research, 2007