Evidence of competency: exploring coach, coachee and expert evaluations of coaching
Authors:
- 1 June 2016
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Coaching: An International Journal of Theory, Research and Practice
- Vol. 9 (2) , 110-128
Abstract
Competency-based coach training and assessment implies that coaching skills and effectiveness are closely related. But who is best placed to determine ‘effectiveness’? While there are some studies comparing coach and coachee evaluations of coaching, none compare a coachee’s evaluation with a coach trainer-assessor’s rating of the coach’s competency in the same encounter. Neither are there studies using coach, coachee and assessor triads. This paper reports on research that examined how closely the evaluations of coachees, expert-assessors and coaches correspond. The research used a novel multi-method approach to triangulation including Clean Language interviewing (CLI) to explore coachees’ experience and evaluation of coaching. Assessor and coachee evaluations of the same coaching session were often at variance, both in terms of descriptive evaluations and numerical ratings. This suggests that compliance – or not – to a coaching methodology does not necessarily guarantee coachee satisfaction. While coach and coachee ratings showed no clear differences, in every triad coaches rated their own coaching considerably better than did the assessor. Practical implications include the need for multiple sources of evidence to establish coach effectiveness and certification standards, the need for coaches to develop calibration skills so they can be more responsive to the coachees’ in-session evaluations, and the usefulness of CLI together with established tools in evaluation research.Keywords
This publication has 26 references indexed in Scilit:
- Why interpersonal dominance and affiliation matter: an interaction analysis of the coach-client relationshipCoaching: An International Journal of Theory, Research and Practice, 2013
- Outcome (competency) based education: an exploration of its origins, theoretical basis, and empirical evidenceAdvances in Health Sciences Education, 2012
- Critical moments in a coaching case study: Illustration of a process research model.Consulting Psychology Journal, 2012
- Executive coaching in practice: what determines helpfulness for clients of coaching?Personnel Review, 2011
- Building successful leadership coaching relationshipsJournal of Management Development, 2010
- Exploring key aspects in the formation of coaching relationships: initial indicators from the perspective of the coachee and the coachCoaching: An International Journal of Theory, Research and Practice, 2010
- Using Numbers in Qualitative ResearchQualitative Inquiry, 2010
- Rigour in qualitative research: mechanisms for controlNurse Researcher, 2009
- Toward a Definition of Mixed Methods ResearchJournal of Mixed Methods Research, 2007
- THE GOAL-FOCUSED COACHING SKILLS QUESTIONNAIRE: PRELIMINARY FINDINGSSocial Behavior and Personality: an international journal, 2007