Abstract
Occupancy models are increasingly applied to data from wildlife camera‐trap (CT) surveys to estimate distribution, habitat use, or relative abundance of unmarked animals. Fundamental to the occupancy modeling framework is the temporal pattern of detections at camera stations, which is influenced by animal population density and the speed and scale of animal movement. How these factors interact withCTsampling designs to affect the interpretation of occupancy parameter estimates is unclear. We developed a simple yet ecologically relevant animal movement simulation to createCTdetections for animal populations varying in movement rate, home range area, and population density. We also variedCTsampling design by the duration of sampling and the density ofCTs in our simulated domain. A single‐species occupancy model was fitted to simulated detection histories, and model‐estimated probabilities of occupancy were compared to the asymptotic proportion of area occupied (PAO), calculated as the union of all simulated home ranges. Occupancy model parameter estimates were sensitive to simulated movement and sampling scenarios. Occupancy models overestimated asymptoticPAOwhen a low population density of simulated animals moved quickly over large home ranges and this positive bias was insensitive to sampling duration. Conversely, asymptoticPAOwas underestimated when simulated animals moved slowly in large‐ or intermediately sized home ranges. This negative bias decreased with increasing sampling duration and a lower density ofCTs. Our results emphasize that the interpretation of occupancy models depends on the underlying processes drivingCTdetections, specifically animal movement and population density, and that model estimates may not reliably reflect variation in these processes. We recommend carefully defining occupancy if it is applied toCTdata in order to better match sampling and analytical frameworks to the ecology of sampled wildlife species.
Funding Information
  • Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada (SFR1451)

This publication has 38 references indexed in Scilit: