The Disciplinary Experience and its Effects on Behaviour: An Exploratory Study
Authors:
- 1 June 1997
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Work, Employment and Society
- Vol. 11 (2) , 283-311
Abstract
Using the results obtained from a small-scale, exploratory study of the internal dynamics of the disciplinary process, two issues are addressed: whether the disciplinary experience results in the disciplined person's internalising and/or observing an organisational rule; and the extent to which this is affected by the way the disciplinary process is handled. It is tentatively concluded that discipline can achieve the outcome of rule internalisation and/or observation, but it does so for only about half of those formally disciplined; for the remaining half, there are ongoing tendencies towards rule breaking. Explanations for this state of affairs are located in two important features of the internal dynamics of disciplinary handling. The first is the implicit use of a `conditioning by punishment' paradigm, which is applied within a context where punishing stimuli are largely ineffective in shaping behaviour. The second, which flows from the first, consists of managerial styles that often create an impression in the eyes of the disciplined person that retributional motives are at work.Keywords
This publication has 33 references indexed in Scilit:
- Disciplinary Practice: A Study of Railways in Britain, 1860-1988Work, Employment and Society, 1994
- JUST AND UNJUST PUNISHMENT: INFLUENCES ON SUBORDINATE PERFORMANCE AND CITIZENSHIP.Academy of Management Journal, 1994
- Industrial Discipline, the Control of Attendance, and the Subordination of Labour: Towards an Integrated AnalysisWork, Employment and Society, 1989
- Employee Reactions to Disciplinary ActionHuman Relations, 1987
- A Field Study of the Use and Perceived Effects of Discipline in Controlling Work Performance.Academy of Management Journal, 1984
- Use of discipline in an organization: A field study.Journal of Applied Psychology, 1984
- Managerial Ideologies and the Use of Discipline.Academy of Management Proceedings, 1981
- An analysis of changes in performance quality with operant conditioning procedures.Journal of Applied Psychology, 1972
- Intensity of punishment, timing of punishment, and cognitive structure as determinants of response inhibitionJournal of Experimental Child Psychology, 1969
- Coercive power and forces affecting conformity.The Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 1960