Comprehensive investigation of sources of misclassification errors in routine HIV testing in Zimbabwe
Authors:
- Simon GregsonSGSimon Gregson
- Louisa MoorhouseLMLouisa Moorhouse
- Tawanda DadiraiTDTawanda Dadirai
- Haynes SheppardHSHaynes Sheppard
- Justin MayiniJMJustin Mayini
- Nadine BeckmannNBNadine Beckmann
- Morten SkovdalMSMorten Skovdal
- Janet DzangareJDJanet Dzangare
- Brian MoyoBMBrian Moyo
- Rufurwokuda MasweraRMRufurwokuda Maswera
- Benjamin A PinskyBPBenjamin A Pinsky
- Sungano MharakurwaSMSungano Mharakurwa
Open Access
- 21 April 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of the International AIDS Society
- Vol. 24 (4) , e25700
Abstract
Introduction: Misclassification errors have been reported in rapid diagnostic HIV tests (RDTs) in sub‐Saharan African countries. These errors can lead to missed opportunities for prevention‐of‐mother‐to‐child‐transmission (PMTCT), early infant diagnosis and adult HIV‐prevention, unnecessary lifelong antiretroviral treatment (ART) and wasted resources. Few national estimates or systematic quantifications of sources of errors have been produced. We conducted a comprehensive assessment of possible sources of misclassification errors in routine HIV testing in Zimbabwe.Methods: RDT‐based HIV test results were extracted from routine PMTCT programme records at 62 sites during national antenatal HIV surveillance in 2017. Positive‐ (PPA) and negative‐percent agreement (NPA) for HIV RDT results and the false‐HIV‐positivity rate for people with previous HIV‐positive results (“known‐positives”) were calculated using results from external quality assurance testing done for HIV surveillance purposes. Data on indicators of quality management systems, RDT kit performance under local climatic conditions and user/clerical errors were collected using HIV surveillance forms, data‐loggers and a Smartphone camera application (7 sites). Proportions of cases with errors were compared for tests done in the presence/absence of potential sources of errors.Results: NPA was 99.9% for both pregnant women (N = 17224) and male partners (N = 2173). PPA was 90.0% (N = 1187) and 93.4% (N = 136) for women and men respectively. 3.5% (N = 1921) of known‐positive individuals on ART were HIV negative. Humidity and temperature exceeding manufacturers’ recommendations, particularly in storerooms (88.6% and 97.3% respectively), and premature readings of RDT output (56.0%) were common. False‐HIV‐negative cases, including interpretation errors, occurred despite staff training and good algorithm compliance, and were not reduced by existing external or internal quality assurance procedures. PPA was lower when testing room humidity exceeded 60% (88.0% vs. 93.3%; p = 0.007).Conclusions: False‐HIV‐negative results were still common in Zimbabwe in 2017 and could be reduced with HIV testing algorithms that use RDTs with higher sensitivity under real‐world conditions and greater practicality under busy clinic conditions, and by strengthening proficiency testing procedures in external quality assurance systems. New false‐HIV‐positive RDT results were infrequent but earlier errors in testing may have resulted in large numbers of uninfected individuals being on ART.Keywords
Funding Information
- Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation (OPP1131208)
- Global Fund to Fight AIDS, Tuberculosis and Malaria (ZIM‐H‐UNDP/1393)
This publication has 17 references indexed in Scilit:
- Potential for False-Positive Results with Serological Assays for HIV in Central Africa: Implications for the HIV Serodiagnosis Algorithm According to the 2015 Consolidated WHO Recommendations for Resource-Constrained CountriesAIDS Research and Human Retroviruses, 2017
- To err is human, to correct is public health: a systematic review examining poor quality testing and misdiagnosis of HIV statusJournal of the International AIDS Society, 2017
- Understanding low sensitivity of community‐based HIV rapid testing: experiences from the HPTN 071 (PopART) trial in Zambia and South AfricaJournal of the International AIDS Society, 2017
- Optimum resource allocation to reduce HIV incidence across sub-Saharan Africa: a mathematical modelling studyThe Lancet HIV, 2016
- Evaluation of Kenya’s readiness to transition from sentinel surveillance to routine HIV testing for antenatal clinic-based HIV surveillanceBMC Infectious Diseases, 2016
- Routine data from prevention of mother-to-child transmission (PMTCT) HIV testing not yet ready for HIV surveillance in Mozambique: a retrospective analysis of matched test resultsBMC Infectious Diseases, 2013
- High HIV incidence during pregnancy: compelling reason for repeat HIV testingAIDS, 2009
- Evaluation of simple rapid HIV assays and development of national rapid HIV test algorithms in Dar es Salaam, TanzaniaBMC Infectious Diseases, 2009
- Evaluation of the Rapid Immunoassay Determine HIV 1/2 for Detection of Antibodies to Human Immunodeficiency Virus Types 1 and 2Journal of Clinical Microbiology, 2003
- Performance of the OraQuick Rapid Antibody Test for Diagnosis of Human Immunodeficiency Virus Type 1 Infection in Patients with Various Levels of Exposure to Highly Active Antiretroviral TherapyJournal of Clinical Microbiology, 2003