Quantification of accuracy in field‐based land cover maps: A new method to separate different components
Open Access
- 2 April 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Applied Vegetation Science
- Vol. 24 (2) , e12578
Abstract
Aim: Many thematic land cover maps, such as maps of vegetation types, are based on field inventories. Studies show inconsistencies among field workers in such maps, explained by inter‐observer variation in classification and/or spatial delineation of polygons. In this study, we have tested a new method to assess the accuracy of these two components independently.Location: Four study sites dominated by different ecosystems in southeast Norway.Methods: We have used a vegetation‐based land cover classification system adapted to a map scale of 1:5,000. First, a consensus map, a map that can be considered an approximation of a flawless map, was established. Secondly, the consensus map was adapted to test the accuracy of classification and polygon delineation independently. We used 10 field workers to generate a consensus map, and 14 new field workers (in pairs) to test the accuracy (n = 7).Results: The results show that the accuracy of polygon delineation is lower than that of land cover classification. This is in contrast with previous studies, but previous research designs have not enabled a separation of the two accuracy components.Conclusion: We recommend strengthening the training and harmonization of field workers in general, and increasing the emphasis on polygon delineation.Keywords
This publication has 28 references indexed in Scilit:
- Impacts of land use on the vegetation in three rural landscapes of NorwayEcosystems and People, 2012
- The repeatability of vegetation classification and mappingJournal of Environmental Management, 2011
- While Boolean sets non-gently rip: A theoretical framework on fuzzy sets for mapping landscape patternsEcological Complexity, 2010
- Using taxonomic data to assess and monitor biodiversity: are the tribes still fighting?Journal of Environmental Monitoring, 2009
- Colour infrared aerial photography as a tool for vegetation mapping and change detection in environmental studies of Nordic ecosystems: A reviewNorsk Geografisk Tidsskrift - Norwegian Journal of Geography, 2007
- Repeatability of Phase 1 habitat surveyJournal of Environmental Management, 2004
- Modelling Environmental Responses of Plant Associations: A Review of Some Critical Concepts in Vegetation StudyCritical Reviews in Plant Sciences, 2004
- Ocular estimates of understory vegetation structure in a closed Picea glauca/Betula papyrifera forestJournal of Vegetation Science, 2000
- Concepts and paradigms in spatial information: are current geographical information systems truly generic?International Journal of Geographical Information Science, 1995
- An investigation of uncertainty in field habitat mapping and the implications for detecting land cover changeLandscape Ecology, 1995