Which characteristics of written feedback are perceived as stimulating students’ reflective competence: an exploratory study
Open Access
- 8 July 2013
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Medical Education
- Vol. 13 (1) , 94
Abstract
Teacher feedback on student reflective writing is recommended to improve learners’ reflective competence. To be able to improve teacher feedback on reflective writing, it is essential to gain insight into which characteristics of written feedback stimulate students’ reflection processes. Therefore, we investigated (1) which characteristics can be distinguished in written feedback comments on reflective writing and (2) which of these characteristics are perceived to stimulate students’ reflection processes. We investigated written feedback comments from forty-three teachers on their students’ reflective essays. In Study 1, twenty-three medical educators grouped the comments into distinct categories. We used Multiple Correspondence Analysis to determine dimensions in the set of comments. In Study 2, another group of twenty-one medical educators individually judged whether the comments stimulated reflection by rating them on a five-point scale. We used t-tests to investigate whether comments classified as stimulating and not stimulating reflection differed in their scores on the dimensions. Our results showed that characteristics of written feedback comments can be described in three dimensions: format of the feedback (phrased as statement versus question), focus of the feedback (related to the levels of students’ reflections) and tone of the feedback (positive versus negative). Furthermore, comments phrased as a question and in a positive tone were judged as stimulating reflection more than comments at the opposite side of those dimensions (t = (14.5) = 6.48; p = < .001 and t = (15) = −1.80; p < .10 respectively). The effect sizes were large for format of the feedback comment (r = .86) and medium for tone of the feedback comment (r = .42). This study suggests that written feedback comments on students’ reflective essays should be formulated as a question, positive in tone and tailored to the individual student’s reflective level in order to stimulate students to reflect on a slightly higher level. Further research is needed to examine whether incorporating these characteristics into teacher training helps to improve the quality of written feedback comments on reflective writing.Keywords
This publication has 31 references indexed in Scilit:
- Feedback in the Emergency Medicine ClerkshipWestern Journal of Emergency Medicine, 2011
- Twelve tips for teaching reflection at all levels of medical educationMedical Teacher, 2010
- Necessary steps in factor analysis: Enhancing validation studies of educational instruments. The PHEEM applied to clerks as an exampleMedical Teacher, 2009
- Building a competency-based curriculum: the agony and the ecstasyAdvances in Health Sciences Education, 2008
- The self critical doctor: helping students become more reflectiveBMJ, 2008
- Reflection and reflective practice in health professions education: a systematic reviewAdvances in Health Sciences Education, 2007
- Assessment of professional behaviour in undergraduate medical education: peer assessment enhances performanceMedical Education, 2007
- Portfolio as a method for continuous assessment in an undergraduate health education programmeMedical Teacher, 2006
- Twelve tips for promoting significant event analysis to enhance reflection in undergraduate medical studentsMedical Teacher, 2002
- The effects of feedback interventions on performance: A historical review, a meta-analysis, and a preliminary feedback intervention theory.Psychological Bulletin, 1996