Irreconcilable differences in Vygotsky’s and Bakhtin’s approaches to the social and the individual: An educational perspective
Author:
- 1 March 2011
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Culture & Psychology
- Vol. 17 (1) , 99-119
Abstract
In Western psychology and education, up until very recently, Bakhtin has often been introduced as a scholar whose approach was compatible with and an extension of Vygotsky’s cultural-historical approach. I argue that this continuity is problematic. Vygotsky’s approach to the social was heavily influenced by Hegel’s universalist, mono-logic, mono-logical, developmental (diachronic), activity-based philosophy. Bakhtin developed a pluralistic, essentially synchronic, dialogic, discourse- and genre-based approach to the social, involving the hybridity of co-existing competing and conflicting varieties of logic. Extrapolating Bakhtin’s approach in education and psychology, I argue that from Bakhtin’s dialogic framework, when a child (or any other person) is a subject of development — as in developmental psychology, or a subject of learning — as in education, development, its goals, and developmental values defining the teleology of the development, become (again) unknown for the participant (e.g., a developmental psychologist or parent).Keywords
This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit:
- Reading and Literature in the Primary and Middle Schools of the Dialogue of CulturesJournal of Russian & East European Psychology, 2009
- The History of World Culture as Curricula of the Middle and High Schools of the Dialogue of CulturesJournal of Russian & East European Psychology, 2009
- Puzzles of the Number and Dialogue in the Early Grades of the School of the Dialogue of CulturesJournal of Russian & East European Psychology, 2009
- A Few Words About Bibler's DialogicsJournal of Russian & East European Psychology, 2009
- Applying a Sociocultural Approach to Vygotskian Academia: `Our Tsar Isn't Like Yours, and Yours Isn't Like Ours'Culture & Psychology, 2008
- In Search of `the Appropriate' Unit of Analysis for Sociocultural ResearchCulture & Psychology, 2007
- When Solo Activity Is Not Privileged: Participation and Internalization Models of DevelopmentHuman Development, 1998
- Intersubjectivity Without AgreementMind, Culture, and Activity, 1996
- Bakhtin and Vygotsky: Internalization as a boundary phenomenonNew Ideas in Psychology, 1993
- The Outer Word and Inner Speech: Bakhtin, Vygotsky, and the Internalization of LanguageCritical Inquiry, 1983