Sustained Control of the Pine Wilt Disease Vector Monochamus alternatus in Pinus thunbergii Forests Depends on Residual Efficacy, Not Initial Knockdown
Open Access
Abstract
Pine wilt disease control often depends on reducing adult beetle activity, but how aerial spraying performs under operational forest management conditions remains poorly understood. We evaluated a 2022 operational aerial spray program in Pinus thunbergii stands in Shandong, China, by combining droplet deposition measurements, branch-feeding bioassays to assess acute and residual toxicity with Monochamus alternatus, and seasonal trap monitoring of both M. alternatus and Arhopalus rusticus, a relevant co-occurring cerambycid species. Spray cards showed that insecticide reached the stand in both spray rounds, although vertical differences between upper and lower strata were stronger during the second application. Branches collected immediately after spraying caused rapid mortality of M. alternatus, and both strata reached complete mortality within 72 h of exposure. In contrast, branches collected one month later caused little additional mortality beyond control levels, indicating that biologically effective exposure declined quickly and provided an insufficient window of protection relative to the full period of adult beetle activity. Trap data matched this pattern. After the first spray, M. alternatus captures dropped sharply during the immediate post-spray period but rebounded before the second spray. A. rusticus showed a similar short-term response, but its seasonal activity pattern differed from that of M. alternatus. Overall, the main limitation of the spray program was not weak initial toxicity, but the short duration of effective control relative to beetle activity in the field. This study shows that better aerial control of pine wilt vectors will depend on matching spray timing and residual persistence with local beetle phenology to improve the design and timing of aerial control programs in pine wilt management.Keywords
Funding Information
- 2022 Procurement Project for Aerial Pesticide Application to Control Monochamus alternatus (6602422344)
- China Scholarship Council (202208370089)
This publication has 46 references indexed in Scilit:
- Global Insights on Insecticide Use in Forest Systems: Current Use, Impacts and Perspectives in a Changing WorldCurrent Forestry Reports, 2024
- A review of pesticide phototransformation on the leaf surface: Models, mechanism, and influencing factorsChemosphere, 2022
- Droplet deposition and pest control efficacy on pine trees from aerial applicationPest Management Science, 2022
- Can insecticide applications used to kill vector insects prevent pine wilt disease?Pest Management Science, 2021
- Investigation of beetle species that carry the pine wood nematode, Bursaphelenchus xylophilus (Steiner and Buhrer) Nickle, in ChinaJournal of Forestry Research, 2020
- Tree pests and diseases: the threat to biodiversity and the delivery of ecosystem servicesBiodiversity and Conservation, 2015
- Aerial Spraying of Neemazal®-T/S Against the Forest Cockchafer (Melolontha hippocastani, Col.: Scarabaeidae) in South-West Germany: The Effects of Two Field Trials Performed in 2007 and 2008 on Local PopulationsJournal of Plant Diseases and Protection, 2015
- Cerambycid Beetle Species with Similar Pheromones are Segregated by Phenology and Minor Pheromone ComponentsJournal of Chemical Ecology, 2015
- Documenting the pesticide processes module of the ARS RZWQM agroecosystem modelPest Management Science, 2004
- Removal of enveloping follicle cells can trigger resumption of meiotic maturation in Fundulus heteroclitus oocytesJournal of Experimental Zoology, 1987