Examiner seniority and experience are associated with bias when scoring communication, but not examination, skills in objective structured clinical examinations in Australia
Open Access
- 18 July 2018
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Korea Health Personnel Licensing Examination Institute in Journal of Educational Evaluation for Health Professions
- Vol. 15, 17
Abstract
Purpose: The biases that may influence objective structured clinical examination (OSCE) scoring are well understood, and recent research has attempted to establish the magnitude of their impact. However, the influence of examiner experience, clinical seniority, and occupation on communication and physical examination scores in OSCEs has not yet been clearly established. Methods: We compared the mean scores awarded for generic and clinical communication and physical examination skills in 2 undergraduate medicine OSCEs in relation to examiner characteristics (gender, examining experience, occupation, seniority, and speciality). The statistical significance of the differences was calculated using the 2-tailed independent t-test and analysis of variance. Results: Five hundred and seventeen students were examined by 237 examiners at the University of New South Wales in 2014 and 2016. Examiner gender, occupation (academic, clinician, or clinical tutor), and job type (specialist or generalist) did not significantly impact scores. Junior doctors gave consistently higher scores than senior doctors in all domains, and this difference was statistically significant for generic and clinical communication scores. Examiner experience was significantly inversely correlated with generic communication scores. Conclusion: We suggest that the assessment of examination skills may be less susceptible to bias because this process is fairly prescriptive, affording greater scoring objectivity. We recommend training to define the marking criteria, teaching curriculum, and expected level of performance in communication skills to reduce bias in OSCE assessment.Keywords
This publication has 8 references indexed in Scilit:
- Examiner effect on the objective structured clinical exam – a study at five medical schoolsBMC Medical Education, 2017
- Reliability and validity of OSCE checklists used to assess the communication skills of undergraduate medical students: A systematic reviewPatient Education and Counseling, 2015
- Are Examiners’ Judgments in OSCE-Style Assessments Influenced by Contrast Effects?Academic Medicine, 2015
- The Influence of Examiner Type on Dental Students’ OSCE ScoresJournal of Dental Education, 2015
- The Objective Structured Clinical Examination (OSCE): AMEE Guide No. 81. Part I: An historical and theoretical perspectiveMedical Teacher, 2013
- Senior medical students as peer examiners in an OSCEMedical Teacher, 2012
- Who You Know or What You Know? Effect of Examiner Familiarity With Residents on OSCE ScoresAcademic Medicine, 2011
- Sources of variation in performance on a shared OSCE station across four UK medical schoolsMedical Education, 2009