The Situational Judgement Test: not the right answer for UK Foundation Programme Allocation

Authors:

Abstract
We were interested therefore to hear of Sahota and colleagues' strong defence of the SJT2 and have carefully considered the points they raise. However, we remain unpersuaded by the arguments made – indeed we have discussed the issues with a wider group of senior academics from UK medical schools (several of whom are additional signatories to this letter), and it is our continued belief that the SJT was not an appropriate method of determining Foundation Programme allocation. To further illustrate this, we provide additional examples of the potential consequences of how an individual candidate's allocation could be dramatically impacted by factors outside of their control.