Abstract
Recent large-scale syntheses of stable isotope data provide an opportunity to reassess published bulk bone collagen δ15N and δ13C values from thousands of individuals across hundreds of archaeological sites in Europe, spanning the Mesolithic to the modern era. Our analyses of this extraordinary dataset reveal that differences in mean isotope values between the sexes from the Neolithic through the Iron Age are small in comparison to differences between chronological periods or across the latitudes of Europe. We find that males are not consistently over-represented among individuals with the highest δ15N values across periods. Contrary to a recent interpretation of the same data as evidence for millennia of gender disparity in Europe, this pattern suggests broad similarities in diet and/or agricultural substrates between sexes before the Middle Ages. To account for the more substantial long-term changes in δ15N values, we suggest that changes in agricultural practices including manuring would have elevated crop δ15N values to a degree comparable to animal protein consumption.