Observing washing and dressing of stroke patients: nursing intervention compared with occupational therapists. What is the difference?
Authors:
- Ian DavidsonIDIan Davidson
- Julie WinstanleyJWJulie Winstanley
- Karen WatersKWKaren Waters
- 1 January 2001
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Advanced Nursing
- Vol. 33 (1) , 98-105
Abstract
Observing washing and dressing of stroke patients: nursing intervention compared with occupational therapists. What is the difference? This study sought to compare the interventions of qualified nurses with those of occupational therapists during morning care with the same population of stroke patients. Nonparticipant structured observation was used to identify the activities and interventions carried out by each of the two groups in a naturalistic care setting. Approval for the study was granted by the local ethics committee. In order to allow comparison between pairs, staff–patient interactions during morning care (n=10) were observed by a single researcher, firstly, with an occupational therapist and within 3 days of this, with a nurse. Twenty observation sessions were recorded in total during which time the activities, contacts and interactions were coded and recorded at 20‐second intervals on a standard proforma. Analysis was undertaken using the Statistical Package for Social Sciences (SPSS) for windows. The results showed that occupational therapists used ‘prompting and instructing’ commands more than nurses and used facilitation techniques significantly more (P=0·0283). ‘Supervision’ interactions were preferred by nurses with 42·1% of their time spent performing this activity compared with 25·1% for occupational therapists. These results are limited to the group under observation. It is suggested that the reasons for the observed differences in intervention styles used by occupational therapists and nurses may be attributed to the approach taken to the assessment and treatment of stroke patients. This difference might be attributed to a lack of preparation for specialist neurological/neurovascular practices of nurses working in the field of stroke rehabilitation.Keywords
This publication has 14 references indexed in Scilit:
- Associated reactions: their value in clinical practice?Physiotherapy Research International, 1998
- Effects of Intensity of Rehabilitation After StrokeStroke, 1997
- Guidance strategies and motor modelling in physiotherapyPhysiotherapy Theory and Practice, 1996
- A Review of Neuroplasticity: Some Implications for Physiotherapy in the Treatment of Lesions of the BrainPhysiotherapy, 1993
- A review of stroke rehabilitation and physiotherapy.Stroke, 1990
- Outcomes of Care within a Multiple-case Study in the Evaluation of the Experimenta National Health Service Nursing HomesAge and Ageing, 1990
- Working TogetherBritish Journal of Occupational Therapy, 1988
- Reconciling Paradigm Assumptions of Qualitative and Quantitative ResearchWestern Journal of Nursing Research, 1988
- Hospital admission for acute stroke: who, for how long, and to what effect?Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health, 1985
- A non-intensive stroke unit reduces functional disability and the need for long-term hospitalization.Stroke, 1985