Patients’ perspectives on ecologically sustainable healthcare in general practice
Preprint
Abstract
Background: Healthcare contributes substantially to climate change. GPs want to implement sustainable healthcare, but are hesitant; worried that this may jeopardise their patient-physician relationship. However, whether this concern is valid is yet to be assessed. Aim: To explore patients’ perspectives on sustainable healthcare in general practice. Design and setting: In 2022 and 2023 we performed an online study, among Dutch GP patients, using experimental vignettes and a questionnaire. Method: The vignettes described GP appointments for three health complaints with randomly allocated treatment advice, varying in sustainability and explanation, but with comparable health outcomes. The questionnaire assessed patients’ perspectives on sustainable healthcare in general practice. We analysed the vignettes using mixed-design ANOVA and the questionnaire using descriptive statistics and correlations. Results: 801 participants completed the vignettes, and 397 the questionnaire. We found no difference on satisfaction with a doctor’s visit ( P ’s>.238) when comparing a sustainable and a non-sustainable treatment option. The effect of explicitly mentioning sustainability differed per health complaint (dyspnoea: no difference; knee pain: MD=.319, P =.002; erythema: MD=-.227, P =.003). In the questionnaire, participants reported positive expectations, and trust in the GP and treatment when delivering sustainable healthcare, but were more neutral about the GPs’ role. Conclusion: We found no indication that sustainable treatment advice leads to lower satisfaction with healthcare. The effect of explicitly mentioning sustainability was minimal and differed per health complaint. When directly asked, patients were mainly positive about sustainable healthcare. These results could encourage GPs to introduce sustainable treatment advice, without worrying about negatively influencing patient satisfaction. How this fits in: GPs and other healthcare professionals increasingly want to implement sustainable healthcare, but are hesitant to do so, fearing that it will jeopardise their patient-physician relationship. However, no studies have been conducted to assess how patients actually respond to sustainable healthcare in general practice. In this study among GP patients, we found: no indication that sustainable treatment advice, in scenarios with comparable health outcomes, leads to lower satisfaction with a doctor’s visit; that the effect of explicitly mentioning sustainability on satisfaction with a doctor’s visit had a minimal effect that differed per health complaint; and that patients were mainly positive about sustainable healthcare when reflecting on this topic in a questionnaire. These findings may encourage GPs to introduce sustainable treatment options in their consultations, without worrying about negatively influencing patient satisfaction.Keywords
All Related Versions
- Published version: BJGP Open, 9 (4).
This publication has 21 references indexed in Scilit:
- The carbon footprint of different modes of birth in the UK and the Netherlands: An exploratory study using life cycle assessmentBJOG: An International Journal of Obstetrics & Gynaecology, 2024
- The 2023 report of the Lancet Countdown on health and climate change: the imperative for a health-centred response in a world facing irreversible harmsThe Lancet, 2023
- The environmental impact of the Dutch health-care sector beyond climate change: an input–output analysisThe Lancet Planetary Health, 2022
- The environmental impact of surgery: A systematic reviewSurgery, 2022
- Discussing climate change and other forms of global environmental change during the clinical encounter: Exploring US physicians’ perspectivesThe Journal of Climate Change and Health, 2021
- Development and validation of a climate change perceptions scaleJournal of Environmental Psychology, 2021
- The environmental footprint of health care: a global assessmentThe Lancet Planetary Health, 2020
- International comparison of health care carbon footprintsEnvironmental Research Letters, 2019
- The Intention–Behavior GapSocial and Personality Psychology Compass, 2016
- Do Americans Understand That Global Warming Is Harmful to Human Health? Evidence From a National SurveyAnnals of Global Health, 2015