Assessment of seasonality and normalization techniques for wastewater-based surveillance in Ontario, Canada
Authors:
Open Access
- 30 August 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Public Health
- Vol. 11, 1186525
Abstract
Introduction: Wastewater-based surveillance is at the forefront of monitoring for community prevalence of COVID-19, however, continued uncertainty exists regarding the use of fecal indicators for normalization of the SARS-CoV-2 virus in wastewater. Using three communities in Ontario, sampled from 2021–2023, the seasonality of a viral fecal indicator (pepper mild mottle virus, PMMoV) and the utility of normalization of data to improve correlations with clinical cases was examined.Methods: Wastewater samples from Warden, the Humber Air Management Facility (AMF), and Kitchener were analyzed for SARS-CoV-2, PMMoV, and crAssphage. The seasonality of PMMoV and flow rates were examined and compared by Season-Trend-Loess decomposition analysis. The effects of normalization using PMMoV, crAssphage, and flow rates were analyzed by comparing the correlations to clinical cases by episode date (CBED) during 2021.Results: Seasonal analysis demonstrated that PMMoV had similar trends at Humber AMF and Kitchener with peaks in January and April 2022 and low concentrations (troughs) in the summer months. Warden had similar trends but was more sporadic between the peaks and troughs for PMMoV concentrations. Flow demonstrated similar trends but was not correlated to PMMoV concentrations at Humber AMF and was very weak at Kitchener (r = 0.12). Despite the differences among the sewersheds, unnormalized SARS-CoV-2 (raw N1–N2) concentration in wastewater (n = 99–191) was strongly correlated to the CBED in the communities (r = 0.620–0.854) during 2021. Additionally, normalization with PMMoV did not improve the correlations at Warden and significantly reduced the correlations at Humber AMF and Kitchener. Flow normalization (n = 99–191) at Humber AMF and Kitchener and crAssphage normalization (n = 29–57) correlations at all three sites were not significantly different from raw N1–N2 correlations with CBED.Discussion: Differences in seasonal trends in viral biomarkers caused by differences in sewershed characteristics (flow, input, etc.) may play a role in determining how effective normalization may be for improving correlations (or not). This study highlights the importance of assessing the influence of viral fecal indicators on normalized SARS-CoV-2 or other viruses of concern. Fecal indicators used to normalize the target of interest may help or hinder establishing trends with clinical outcomes of interest in wastewater-based surveillance and needs to be considered carefully across seasons and sites.Keywords
Funding Information
- Canada First Research Excellence Fund
- Canada Research Chairs
This publication has 42 references indexed in Scilit:
- Wastewater SARS-CoV-2 RNA Concentration and Loading Variability from Grab and 24-Hour Composite SamplesmedRxiv, 2020
- Pepper mild mottle virus: Agricultural menace turned effective tool for microbial water quality monitoring and assessing (waste)water treatment technologiesPLOS Pathogens, 2019
- Pepper mild mottle virus as a water quality indicatornpj Clean Water, 2018
- Quantitative CrAssphage PCR Assays for Human Fecal Pollution MeasurementEnvironmental Science & Technology, 2017
- cocor: A Comprehensive Solution for the Statistical Comparison of CorrelationsPLOS ONE, 2015
- Metagenomic Evaluation of the Highly Abundant Human Gut Bacteriophage CrAssphage for Source Tracking of Human Fecal PollutionEnvironmental Science & Technology Letters, 2014
- Pepper Mild Mottle Virus as an Indicator of Fecal PollutionApplied and Environmental Microbiology, 2009
- The MIQE Guidelines: Minimum Information for Publication of Quantitative Real-Time PCR ExperimentsClinical Chemistry, 2009
- Toward using confidence intervals to compare correlations.Psychological Methods, 2007
- RNA Viral Community in Human Feces: Prevalence of Plant Pathogenic VirusesPLOS Biology, 2005