Reproducing Italians: contested biopolitics in the age of ‘replacement anxiety’
- 13 August 2012
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Anthropology & Medicine
- Vol. 19 (2) , 171-188
Abstract
In national and international discourses, Italians are often represented as a greying population failing to reproduce itself. Italian women are targeted for their very low birth rates, while migrant women are scrutinized for their 'excessive' fertility and abortion rates. These demographic concerns over differential reproduction reflect 'replacement anxiety' about the below-replacement rates of Italians and the replacement of Italians by immigrants. Demographic anxieties coalesce with the intensifying of Catholic 'vitapolitics' manifesting in the paradox of pro-natalist interventions coexisting with the curtailment of fertility-enhancing reproductive technologies. The children of migrants emerge in some population discourses as a threat rather than a contribution to the reproduction of the nation. Drawing on multi-sited ethnographic research in Milan, this paper examines how reproduction in contemporary Italy has emerged as a contested social, political, and moral issue that invests Italian and migrant women in different ways, engendering different forms and terms of resistance and contestation. On what terms are subjects governed and called upon to govern themselves to be more 'rational' and 'responsible' reproducers of the nation? What subjectivities and local responses are engendered by the politics of reproduction in Italy? As different rationalities and notions of responsible reproduction circulate, ethnographic research sheds light on how anxieties over low birth rates are reappropriated and redeployed against the state, suggesting that subjects are not so easily governable by population and reproductive discourses. This research contributes to the literature on critical demography and the politics of reproduction and migration in the new Europe.Keywords
This publication has 23 references indexed in Scilit:
- Immigrant fertility in West Germany: Is there a socialization effect in transitions to second and third births?European Journal of Population, 2010
- Precarious Subjects: Anticipating Neoliberalism in Northern Italy's WorkplaceAmerican Anthropologist, 2010
- Lowest-Low Fertility: Signs of a recovery in Italy?Demographic Research, 2009
- Gender Equity and Fertility in Italy and SpainJournal of Social Policy, 2009
- Demographic Transitions and ModernityAnnual Review of Anthropology, 2008
- Fertility Politics as “Social Viagra”: Reproducing Boundaries, Social Cohesion, and Modernity in ItalyAmerican Anthropologist, 2007
- On Cultures of DemocracyPublic Culture, 2007
- The Social Construction of Population Science: An Intellectual, Institutional, and Political History of Twentieth-Century DemographyComparative Studies in Society and History, 1996
- Flowers for the Doctor: Pro-Natalism and Abortion in Fascist MilanModern Italy, 1996
- Constructing the sterile city: pronatalism and social sciences in interwar ItalyAmerican Ethnologist, 1991