Just because you’re paranoid doesn’t mean they won’t side with the plaintiff: Examining perceptions of liability about AI in radiology
Preprint
Abstract
Background Artificial Intelligence (AI) will have unintended consequences for radiology. When a radiologist misses an abnormality on an image, their liability may differ according to whether or not AI also missed the abnormality. Methods U.S. adults viewed a vignette describing a radiologist being sued for missing a brain bleed (N=652) or cancer (N=682). Participants were randomized to one of five conditions. In four conditions, they were told an AI system was used. Either AI agreed with the radiologist, also failing to find pathology (AI agree) or did find pathology (AI disagree). In the AI agree+FOR condition, AI agreed with the radiologist and an AI false omission rate (FOR) of 1% was presented. In the AI disagree+FDR condition, AI disagreed and an AI false discovery rate (FDR) of 50% was presented. There was also a no AI control condition. Otherwise, vignettes were identical. Participants indicated whether the radiologist met their duty of care as a proxy for whether they would side with defense (radiologist) or plaintiff in trial. Results Participants were more likely to side with the plaintiff in the AI disagree vs. AI agree condition (brain bleed: 72.9% vs. 50.0%, p=0.0054; cancer: 78.7% vs. 63.5%, p=0.00365) and in the AI disagree vs. no AI condition (brain bleed: 72.9% vs. 56.3%, p=0.0054; cancer: 78.7% vs. 65.2%, p=0.00895). Participants were less likely to side with the plaintiff when FDR or FOR were provided: AI disagree vs AI disagree+FDR (brain bleed: 72.9% vs. 48.8%, p=0.00005; cancer: 78.7% vs. 73.1%, p=0.1507), and AI agree vs. AI agree+FOR (brain bleed: 50.0% vs. 34.0%, p=0.0044; cancer: 63.5% vs. 56.4%, p=0.1085). Discussion Radiologists who failed to find an abnormality are viewed as more culpable when they used an AI system that detected the abnormality. Presenting participants with AI accuracy data decreased perceived liability. These findings have relevance for courtroom proceedings.Keywords
This publication has 10 references indexed in Scilit:
- When AIs outperform doctors: confronting the challenges of a tort-induced over-reliance on machine learning2025
- Understanding Liability Risk from Using Health Care Artificial Intelligence ToolsNew England Journal of Medicine, 2024
- Defining medical liability when artificial intelligence is applied on diagnostic algorithms: a systematic reviewFrontiers in Medicine, 2023
- The unintended consequences of artificial intelligence in paediatric radiologyPediatric Radiology, 2023
- Can incorrect artificial intelligence (AI) results impact radiologists, and if so, what can we do about it? A multi-reader pilot study of lung cancer detection with chest radiographyEuropean Radiology, 2023
- When Artificial Intelligence Models Surpass Physician Performance: Medical Malpractice Liability in an Era of Advanced Artificial IntelligenceJournal of the American College of Radiology, 2022
- How does artificial intelligence in radiology improve efficiency and health outcomes?Pediatric Radiology, 2021
- Overdiagnosis and overtreatment; how to deal with too much medicineJournal of Family Medicine and Primary Care, 2020
- When AIs Outperform Doctors: The Dangers of a Tort-Induced Over-Reliance on Machine Learning and What (Not) to Do About itSSRN Electronic Journal, 2018
- The Causes of Medical Malpractice Suits against Radiologists in the United StatesRadiology, 2013