Problem Perspectives and Grizzly Bears: A Case Study of Alberta’s Grizzly Bear Recovery Policy
Authors:
Open Access
- 11 March 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution
- Vol. 8
Abstract
Since their threatened species listing in 2010, grizzly bear recovery has been a controversial policy issue in Alberta, Canada particularly because this charismatic carnivore represents a diverse set of values, both positive (e.g., an icon of beauty and the wilderness) and negative (e.g., a safety threat and economic risk to peoples’ livelihoods). Previous human dimensions research on grizzly bear conservation has accounted for the values and attitudes different groups of people hold for these bears, as well as their views on conflict mitigation strategies. However, the conservation literature is more limited in assessing the perspectives different people hold for grizzly bear conservation in a policy context. Arguably, understanding the policy landscape in which carnivore conservation occurs is important to achieve desired goals and objectives for species and the people expected to live with them and implement policy action. Using a case study approach between 2012 and 2014 and borrowing from the policy sciences problem-oriented framework, we identify the dominant problem perspectives in Alberta’s grizzly bear recovery policy using document review and interviews with participants from government, the natural resource sector, and environmental non-governmental organizations. We identify that ordinary and constitutive problem perspectives share common features across participants in this study, including frustrations with lack of policy clarity, implementation inefficiencies and committed political and financial action, and perhaps even more important, the challenges in policy decision-making and governance. We discuss the importance of meaningful engagement of people who live with large carnivores and the impacts of conservation policy, which is applicable to both a local and global scale, as success in large carnivore conservation must include the people who will ultimately implement conservation action.Keywords
This publication has 52 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Problem with Problem Definition: Mapping the Discursive Terrain of Conservation in Two Pacific Salmon Management RegimesSociety & Natural Resources, 2011
- Maintaining Complex Relations with Large Cats: Maasai and Lions in Kenya and TanzaniaHuman Dimensions of Wildlife, 2010
- Participatory Planning of Interventions to Mitigate Human–Wildlife ConflictsConservation Biology, 2009
- A Problem-Oriented Overview of Management Policy for Podocarpus National Park, EcuadorJournal of Sustainable Forestry, 2009
- Stakeholder participation for environmental management: A literature reviewBiological Conservation, 2008
- Power in Natural Resources Management: An Application of TheorySociety & Natural Resources, 2008
- Is there a bias against telephone interviews in qualitative research?Research in Nursing & Health, 2008
- Social Capital in Biodiversity Conservation and ManagementConservation Biology, 2004
- Crafting Effective Solutions to the Large Carnivore Conservation ProblemConservation Biology, 1996
- Making Sense of the Policy Process for Carnivore ConservationConservation Biology, 1996