Gaps in Framing and Naming: Commentary to “A Viewpoint on Accent Services”
Authors:
Open Access
- 12 July 2022
- journal article
- editorial
- Published by American Speech Language Hearing Association in American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology
- Vol. 31 (4) , 1913-1918
Abstract
Purpose: In this commentary, we offer a critique of “A Viewpoint on Accent Services: Framing and Terminology Matter” (Grover et al., 2022). We argue that the authors' proposal to rename and reframe accent modification lacks criticality, which actually hinders—rather than advances—the movement toward equitable, culturally sustaining, and emancipatory practices. Method: We offer an analysis of the shortfall between the authors' calls for linguistic justice in “A Viewpoint on Accent Services” and the actual changes they proposed. We break down major gaps in criticality, reflexivity, practice, and vision and discuss their potential for undercutting meaningful progress as it relates to linguistic justice. Results: We found that the frameworks for the pursuit of equity, cultural sustenance, and emancipatory practices were misrepresented in the article in such a way that suggests that these goals could be achieved through superficial changes in terminology and attitudes. “A Viewpoint on Accent Services” upholds a power-neutral frame of operation that does not address the deeper systemic forces that make accent modification problematic. The lack of criticality toward accent intervention fosters complacency toward real transformation. Conclusion: We advocate for a serious and critical interrogation of accent practices and commitment to an emancipatory practice that addresses linguistic discrimination above all else. We emphasize the need to decenter standardized languages and to co-envision linguistic liberation using critical methods in scholarship, pedagogy, clinical practice, and policy.Keywords
This publication has 13 references indexed in Scilit:
- Rejecting abyssal thinking in the language and education of racialized bilinguals: A manifestoCritical Inquiry in Language Studies, 2021
- Linguistic Justice2020
- Racializing the problem of and solution to foreign accent in businessApplied Linguistics Review, 2019
- Raciolinguistics2016
- Rethinking the Role of “Culture” in Educational Equity: From Cultural Competence to Equity LiteracyMulticultural Perspectives, 2016
- Accent Policy and Accent Modification Enterprises as Potential Indicators of Intercultural Power Relations: A Call for an Updated Research AgendaPerspectives on Global Issues in Communication Sciences and Related Disorders, 2013
- Foreign Accent: The Phenomenon of Non-native Speech2013
- Culturally Sustaining PedagogyEducational Researcher, 2012
- English with an Accent2012
- Toward a Theory of Culturally Relevant PedagogyAmerican Educational Research Journal, 1995