The comparative effectiveness of gesture and verbal treatments for a specific phonologic naming impairment
Authors:
- Miranda RoseMRMiranda Rose
- Jacinta DouglasJDJacinta Douglas
- Thomas MatyasTMThomas Matyas
- 1 October 2002
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Aphasiology
- Vol. 16 (10-11) , 1001-1030
Abstract
Background: Arm and hand gesture has been considered a potential facilitator of word production (Skelly, Schinsky, Smith, & Fust, 1974), and gesture is often considered as a therapeutic modality for the treatment of aphasia (Rao, 1994), but there is limited empirical evidence of the efficacy of gesture-based treatments. Models of the relationship between word production and gesture production have been developed (Hadar & Butterworth, 1997; Krauss & Hadar, 1999) but they are currently under-specified and provide little guidance as to whether gesture might be an efficacious treatment for word production deficits arising from particular underlying levels of impairment. Aims: This study had two main aims: First, to examine the comparative facilitation effects of gesture production and visualisation processes on object naming skills, and second, to compare the effectiveness of three types of treatment, gesture, verbal, and combined verbal plus gesture, for word production deficits arising from impairment at the level of phonological access and encoding. Methods & Procedures: A 68-year-old female, AB, participated in the study. AB sustained a single, left, frontoparietal, subarachnoid haemorrhage 6 months prior to the study, which resulted in a highly specific, mild, phonologic access and encoding impairment. AB initially participated in a trial comparing the relative effectiveness of gesture and visualisation processes for facilitating oral picture naming. A controlled multiple-baseline single-case experiment was then carried out comparing the three naming treatments. Outcomes & Results: The use of iconic gesture was found to significantly facilitate picture naming. Pointing, visualisation, and cued articulation produced negligible change from baseline rates. Clinically and statistically significant treatment effects were found for all three treatment conditions, with only marginal differences between conditions. Improvements made in picture naming were maintained at 1 and 3 month follow-up assessments and generalisation of enhanced object naming was found with novel stimuli and during spontaneous conversation. Conclusions: The results supported Krauss and Hadar's (1999) model of speech and gesture production, suggesting frank interaction between the kinesic monitor of the gesture production system and the formulator of the word production system. The results caution clinicians to question the long-held axiom of the superiority of multi-modality treatments, and encourage clinicians to consider the underlying knowledge and processes generated by particular treatment protocols, rather than simply the modality in which the treatment is transmitted.Keywords
This publication has 49 references indexed in Scilit:
- Iconic hand gestures and the predictability of words in context in spontaneous speechBritish Journal of Psychology, 2000
- An experimental investigation of the role of iconic gestures in lexical access using the tip‐of‐the‐tongue phenomenonBritish Journal of Psychology, 1999
- Do iconic hand gestures really contribute anything to the semantic information conveyed by speech? An experimental investigationSemiotica, 1999
- Do iconic gestures have a functional role in lexical access? An experimental study of the effects of repeating a verbal message on gesture productionSemiotica, 1998
- Gestures and words during the transition to two-word speechJournal of Child Language, 1996
- Gestures, pauses and speech: An experimental investigation of the effects of changing social context on their precise temporal relationshipsSemiotica, 1994
- Gesture, speech, and computational stages: A reply to McNeill.Psychological Review, 1989
- Handedness and Its Relation to Cerebral Function1982
- Gestures and Lexical Processes in Jargonaphasia1981
- Gesture and Silence as Indicators of Planning in Speech1978