Ultrasound elastography of back muscle biomechanical properties: a systematic review and meta-analysis of current methods
Authors:
Open Access
- 14 August 2024
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Springer Nature in Insights into Imaging
- Vol. 15 (1) , 1-17
Abstract
Objectives: To report the current elastography methods used to quantify back muscles’ biomechanical characteristics in patients with musculoskeletal disorders (MSKd) and inform on their reliability, validity, and responsiveness. Methods: MEDLINE, Embase, CINAHL, Cochrane library and grey literature were consulted. Predefined criteria allowed for study selection and data extraction. The quality of evidence was rated using the COSMIN tool. Data were meta-analyzed in terms of pooled intraclass correlation coefficient (pICC) for reliability and pooled standardized mean difference (pSMD) for validity and responsiveness. Heterogeneity was assessed. Results: Seventy-nine studies were included in the meta-analysis (total number of participants N = 3178). Three elastography methods were identified: strain imaging (SI; number of cohorts M = 26), shear wave imaging (SWI; M = 50), and vibration sonoelastography (VSE; M = 3). Strain imaging and SWI studies reported good reliability measurement properties (pICC > 0.70) and a medium pSMD (0.58 for SI and 0.60 for SWI; p ≤ 0.020) in discriminating MSKd from controls’ condition (validity). Strain imaging studies reported a medium pSMD (0.64; p = 0.005) in detecting within-group changes over time, whereas SWI pSMD was very high (1.24; p = 0.005). Only SWI reported significant but small pSMD (0.30; p = 0.003) in detecting between-group changes over time. The small number of VSE studies could not be meta-analyzed. Heterogeneity was high (I-squared > 90%; p < 0.001). Conclusions: Elastography presents good reliability results and a medium pSMD in discriminating MSKd from control conditions. Responsiveness data suggest detectable changes within groups over time using SI and SWI, calling for long-term longitudinal studies. Assessing changes between groups over time using elastography still needs to be proven. Highly significant heterogeneity limits meta-analytic results. Critical relevance statement: While still in its early-stage exploration phase, musculoskeletal ultrasound elastography may reliably quantify back muscles’ biomechanics in asymptomatic individuals, moderately discriminate back musculoskeletal disorders and detect biomechanical changes over time in these conditions, calling for long-term longitudinal studies. Key Points: Ultrasound elastography is reviewed for back pain and related musculoskeletal disorder assessments. Growing literature supports good reproducibility, some validity and responsiveness. Back muscle elastography considers assumptions calling for standardized protocols. GraphicalKeywords
Funding Information
- Fonds Québécois de la Recherche sur la Nature et les Technologies (#302254)
This publication has 123 references indexed in Scilit:
- Ultrasound evidence of altered lumbar fascia in patients with low back painClinical Anatomy, 2022
- Can measuring passive neck muscle stiffness in whiplash injury patients help detect false whiplash claims?Wiener klinische Wochenschrift, 2020
- Ultrasound Shear Wave Elastography to Assess Osteopathic Manipulative Treatment on the Iliocostalis Lumborum Muscle: A Feasibility StudyJournal of Ultrasound in Medicine, 2019
- Increased Stiffness of Rotator Cuff Tendons in Frozen Shoulder on Shear Wave ElastographyJournal of Ultrasound in Medicine, 2019
- Influence of thoracolumbar fascia stretching on lumbar back muscle stiffness: A supersonic shear wave elastography approachClinical Anatomy, 2018
- Shear Wave Elastography of the Lumbar Multifidus Muscle in Patients With Unilateral Lumbar Disk HerniationJournal of Ultrasound in Medicine, 2018
- Shear wave sonoelastography of skeletal muscle: basic principles, biomechanical concepts, clinical applications, and future perspectivesSkeletal Radiology, 2017
- Feasibility assessment of shear wave elastography to lumbar back musclesClinical Anatomy, 2017
- Shear wave elastography reveals different degrees of passive and active stiffness of the neck extensor musclesEuropean Journal of Applied Physiology, 2016
- Changes in stiffness of the dorsal scapular muscles before and after computer work: a comparison between individuals with and without neck and shoulder complaintsEuropean Journal of Applied Physiology, 2016