What Would Miffy Do? Applying Informed Consent by Proxy to All Sentient Animals
Open Access
Abstract
If we want to take sentient non-human animals and their interests seriously, we can try to ask for their consent before using them for human purposes. With mentally competent humans, we speak of informed consent: for them to participate in scientific studies, for example, it is required that they consent explicitly, in full understanding of the risks and benefits. This full understanding cannot be expected from non-human animals. We must therefore look for ways to know what they want and to estimate what they would do if they had a deep understanding of their options and the consequences of these options for themselves and others. This concept is explored by applying it to animal experiments. The most promising method is to gain informed consent by proxy from thoroughly informed competent humans, in combination with seeking assent where possible and being alert to dissent.Keywords
This publication has 29 references indexed in Scilit:
- Cortical regulation of helping behaviour towards others in painNature, 2024
- Handling End-of-Life Situations in Small Animal Practice: What Strategies do Veterinarians Contemplate During their Decision-Making Process?Journal of Applied Animal Welfare Science, 2023
- Examining interspecies interactions in light of discourse analytic theory: A case study on the genre of human-goat communication at a petting farmLanguage & Communication, 2021
- Interspecies justice: agency, self-determination, and assentPhilosophical Studies, 2020
- Holding Animal-Based Research to Our Highest Ethical Standards: Re-seeing Two Emergent Laboratory Practices and the Ethical Significance of Research Animal DissentILAR Journal, 2019
- Betraying AnimalsThe Journal of Ethics, 2019
- Informed consent—It's more than a signature on a piece of paperThe American Journal of Surgery, 2017
- Is There a Role for Assent or Dissent in Animal Research?Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics, 2015
- Animal Rights2009
- Proxy Decision Making for Incompetent PatientsJAMA, 1992