Neonicotinoid seed treatment on sugar beet in England: a qualitative analysis of the controversy, existing policy and viability of alternatives
Open Access
- 15 April 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Environmental Studies and Sciences
- Vol. 13 (3) , 453-472
Abstract
In 2021, the United Kingdom Government granted the possibility of an emergency derogation for the use of the neonicotinoid seed treatment, thiamethoxam, on sugar beet in England. This was met with heavy criticism and controversy due to the body of evidence demonstrating toxicity of the insecticide to non-target species, particularly pollinators. However, many viewed this decision to be reasonable in this system, as sugar beet is a non-flowering crop, and derogations were only implemented if a set of conditions, including viral risk, were met. This research aims to understand the policy and the perspective of stakeholders in this debate, and identify key problems associated with thiamethoxam use on sugar beet. Semi-structured interviews combined with a modified policy analysis were used, incorporating framework analysis and comparative analysis. Political polarisation, whereby respondents felt that the debate had become anti-pesticide or pro-pesticide and lacked nuance, and the monopsony of British Sugar (a UK company that buys and processes sugar beet), were found to be the most prevalent issues currently impeding political progress and the enhancement of sustainable agriculture in this system. Virus forecasting was considered a successful strategy at the time of writing, although limitations to the model are also discussed. Non-chemical alternatives were found to be limited in this system due to the specificity of the pest system and the low threshold of virus yellows, while forecasting was considered to have the lowest net-environmental impact. Additional policy strategies to work alongside forecasting, such as public education and intergroup contact are also discussed. This study reflects a more general tug-of-war that often sets up a false dichotomy between food security and environmental sustainability. It highlights the importance of addressing the complexity of sustainable food production by opening up the discussion and taking a more nuanced and adaptive approach to policy.Keywords
This publication has 80 references indexed in Scilit:
- A Four-Year Field Program Investigating Long-Term Effects of Repeated Exposure of Honey Bee Colonies to Flowering Crops Treated with ThiamethoxamPLOS ONE, 2013
- Data, Data Everywhere But We Don't Know What to Think? Neonicotinoid Insecticides and PollinatorsOutlooks on Pest Management, 2013
- Experimental exposure of red-legged partridges (Alectoris rufa) to seeds coated with imidacloprid, thiram and difenoconazoleEcotoxicology, 2012
- Effects of imidacloprid, a neonicotinoid pesticide, on reproduction in worker bumble bees (Bombus terrestris)Ecotoxicology, 2012
- A meta-analysis of experiments testing the effects of a neonicotinoid insecticide (imidacloprid) on honey beesEcotoxicology, 2010
- Impacts of a pesticide on pollinator species richness at different spatial scalesBasic and Applied Ecology, 2010
- Risk assessment for side-effects of neonicotinoids against bumblebees with and without impairing foraging behaviorEcotoxicology, 2009
- Insecticide use: Contexts and ecological consequencesAgriculture and Human Values, 2007
- The Impact of Public Opinion on Public Policy: A Review and an AgendaPolitical Research Quarterly, 2003
- The transmission of beet mosaic and beet yellows viruses by aphides; a comparative study of a non-persistent and a persistent virus having host plants and vectors in commonProceedings of the Royal Society of London. B. Biological Sciences, 1946