Abstract
In social species, hierarchies emerge across diverse behavioral contexts, including dyadic contests, resource competition, and territorial marking. Whether competitive success generalizes across these contexts remains unclear, in part because individual performance and hierarchy structure are difficult to compare directly across assays. Here, we establish a framework for such comparisons using three behavioral paradigms (the tube test, the warm spot assay, and the void spot assay) in same-sex triads of BALB/c and C57BL/6 mice, as well as Shank3B knockouts, which exhibit impaired social recognition. Hierarchies emerged in all three assays, but their structure and behavioral determinants differed by strain and sex. In the tube test, BALB and C57 mice employed different contest-resolution strategies, while Shank3b⁻/⁻ females exhibited diminished winner effects and reduced hierarchy stability. In the warm spot assay, females of all strains established stronger hierarchies than males, with high-ranking individuals actively displacing competitors from the warm platform. In the void spot assay, clear hierarchical organization emerged in BALB mice of both sexes and C57 males but was attenuated in Shank3b⁻/⁻ mice. Despite repeatable individual performance and stable hierarchies within each assay, performance was weakly correlated between assays, and social rank rarely generalized across behavioral contexts. Together, these findings reveal strain- and sex-dependent strategies for establishing social hierarchies, implicate Shank3b in winner effects and hierarchy stability, and demonstrate that competitive ability is multidimensional rather than a single, generalized trait, suggesting that distinct mechanisms may govern competitive success across behavioral domains.