How best to collect demographic data for population viability analysis models
Open Access
- 23 November 2005
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Applied Ecology
- Vol. 42 (6) , 1115-1120
Abstract
Summary: Matrix population models have become important tools in many fields of ecology and conservation biology, and are the most commonly used method in population viability analysis (PVA). There is a large literature concerned with different aspects of matrix model analysis, but relatively little attention has been paid to how data are collected. In most demographic population viability studies, data are sampled in permanent plots, often resulting in poor representation of some stages. It has been suggested that by using previous knowledge of species’ demography it is possible to sample demographic data more efficiently. Here we propose an alternative method that is much simpler and does not rely on any assumptions, namely sampling an equal number of individuals per stage. By using demographic data from 32 species we showed that sampling an equal number of individuals per stage provides more precise estimates of both population growth rate and elasticity than the traditional plot‐based method. In some cases it is also better than the estimates gained using the method based on previous knowledge of the species’ demography. The conclusions of the latter method are very sensitive to the quality of the previous knowledge of the species’ demography. In contrast, collecting demographic data from an equal number of individuals per stage is independent of any assumptions. Synthesis and applications. A central aim for management of threatened species is to develop robust and accurate methods for assessing population viability that are also efficient in terms of costs and labour. A key issue is how to collect the data on which viability assessments are based. We show that it is possible to increase considerably the accuracy and robustness of demographic PVA without increasing sampling effort, by using a simple method based on sampling an equal number of individuals per life‐cycle stage. Improved PVA model performance will be important to guide conservation efforts and to evaluate different management options.Keywords
This publication has 22 references indexed in Scilit:
- EFFECTS OF AN INTRODUCED PATHOGEN AND FIRE EXCLUSION ON THE DEMOGRAPHY OF SUGAR PINEEcological Applications, 2004
- The effect of density‐dependent catastrophes on population persistence timeJournal of Applied Ecology, 2003
- Predicting the impacts of harvesting using structured population models: the importance of density‐dependence and timing of harvest for a tropical palm treeJournal of Applied Ecology, 2003
- EFFICIENT DATA COLLECTION FOR ESTIMATING GROWTH RATES OF STRUCTURED POPULATIONSEcology, 2002
- Evaluating the Extinction Risk of a Perennial Herb: Demographic Data versus Historical RecordsConservation Biology, 2002
- Reliability of Elasticity Analysis: Reply to Mills et al.Conservation Biology, 2001
- Reliability of Elasticity Analysis: Reply to Mills et al.Conservation Biology, 2001
- WHEN IS IT MEANINGFUL TO ESTIMATE AN EXTINCTION PROBABILITY?Ecology, 2000
- IS IT MEANINGFUL TO ESTIMATE A PROBABILITY OF EXTINCTION?Ecology, 1999
- Direct Perturbation Analysis for Better ConservationConservation Biology, 1998