When is an optimization not an optimization? Evaluation of clinical implications of information content (signal-to-noise ratio) in optimization of cardiac resynchronization therapy, and how to measure and maximize it
Open Access
- 26 November 2010
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Heart Failure Reviews
- Vol. 16 (3) , 277-290
Abstract
Impact of variability in the measured parameter is rarely considered in designing clinical protocols for optimization of atrioventricular (AV) or interventricular (VV) delay of cardiac resynchronization therapy (CRT). In this article, we approach this question quantitatively using mathematical simulation in which the true optimum is known and examine practical implications using some real measurements. We calculated the performance of any optimization process that selects the pacing setting which maximizes an underlying signal, such as flow or pressure, in the presence of overlying random variability (noise). If signal and noise are of equal size, for a 5-choice optimization (60, 100, 140, 180, 220 ms), replicate AV delay optima are rarely identical but rather scattered with a standard deviation of 45 ms. This scatter was overwhelmingly determined (ρ = −0.975, P < 0.001) by Information Content, \( {\frac{\text{Signal}}{{{\text{Signal}} + {\text{Noise}}}}} \), an expression of signal-to-noise ratio. Averaging multiple replicates improves information content. In real clinical data, at resting, heart rate information content is often only 0.2–0.3; elevated pacing rates can raise information content above 0.5. Low information content (e.g. <0.5) causes gross overestimation of optimization-induced increment in VTI, high false-positive appearance of change in optimum between visits and very wide confidence intervals of individual patient optimum. AV and VV optimization by selecting the setting showing maximum cardiac function can only be accurate if information content is high. Simple steps to reduce noise such as averaging multiple replicates, or to increase signal such as increasing heart rate, can improve information content, and therefore viability, of any optimization process.
Keywords
This publication has 16 references indexed in Scilit:
- Comparison of a non-invasive arterial pulse contour technique and echo Doppler aorta velocity-time integral on stroke volume changes in optimization of cardiac resynchronization therapyEP Europace, 2010
- A Prospective Comparison of AV Delay Programming Methods for Hemodynamic Optimization during Cardiac Resynchronization TherapyJournal of Cardiovascular Electrophysiology, 2007
- Temporal Variation in Optimal Atrioventricular and Interventricular Delay During Cardiac Resynchronization TherapyJournal of Cardiac Failure, 2006
- Haemodynamic effects of changes in atrioventricular and interventricular delay in cardiac resynchronisation therapy show a consistent pattern: analysis of shape, magnitude and relative importance of atrioventricular and interventricular delayHeart, 2006
- Determination of optimal atrioventricular delay for cardiac resynchronization therapy using acute non-invasive blood pressureEP Europace, 2006
- Rate‐Dependent AV Delay Optimization in Cardiac Resynchronization TherapyPacing and Clinical Electrophysiology, 2005
- Effect of Pacing Chamber and Atrioventricular Delay on Acute Systolic Function of Paced Patients With Congestive Heart FailureCirculation, 1999
- Improved Left Ventricular Mechanics From Acute VDD Pacing in Patients With Dilated Cardiomyopathy and Ventricular Conduction DelayCirculation, 1999
- The pacing therapies for congestive heart failure (PATH-CHF) study: rationale, design, and endpoints of a prospective randomized multicenter study11For a complete list of institutions and individuals participating in the PATH-CHF Study Group, see the Appendix.The American Journal of Cardiology, 1999
- Hemodynamic effects of acute atrioventricular sequential pacing in patients with left ventricular dysfunctionThe American Journal of Cardiology, 1982