Similarities, Differences and Synergisms Between HERA and LCA—An Analysis at Three Levels
- 1 July 2006
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Human and Ecological Risk Assessment: An International Journal
- Vol. 12 (3) , 431-449
Abstract
Linkages between Human and Environmental Risk Assessment (HERA) and Life-Cycle Assessment (LCA) can be analyzed at three levels: the basic equations to describe environmental behavior and dose-response relationships of chemicals; the overall model structure of these tools; and the applications of the tools. At level 1 few differences exist: both tools use essentially the same fate and effect models, including their coefficients and data. At level 2 distinctive differences emerge: regional or life-cycle perspective, emission pulses or fluxes, scope of chemicals and types of impacts, use of characterization factors, spatial and temporal detail, aggregation of effects, and the functional unit as basis of the assessment. Although the two tools typically differ in all these aspects, only the functional unit issue renders the tools fundamentally different, expressing itself also in some main characteristics of the modeling structure. This impedes full integration, which is underpinned in mathematical terms. At level 3 the aims of the tools are complementary: quantified risk estimates of chemicals for HERA versus quantified product assessment for LCA. Here, beneficial synergism is possible between the two tools, as illustrated by some cases. These also illustrate that where full integration is suggested, in practice this is not achieved, thus in fact supporting the conclusions.Keywords
This publication has 25 references indexed in Scilit:
- Life cycle assessment Part 2: Current impact assessment practiceEnvironment International, 2004
- BETR-World: a geographically explicit model of chemical fate: application to transport of α-HCH to the ArcticEnvironmental Pollution, 2004
- Biotic ligand model of the acute toxicity of metals. 1. Technical BasisEnvironmental Toxicology and Chemistry, 2001
- Life cycle impact assessment and risk assessment of chemicals — a methodological comparisonEnvironmental Impact Assessment Review, 2001
- Human toxicity potentials for life-cycle assessment and toxics release inventory risk screeningEnvironmental Toxicology and Chemistry, 2001
- A risk-based approach to life-cycle impact assessmentJournal of Hazardous Materials, 1998
- Life‐Cycle Assessment in Relation to Risk Assessment: An Evolving PerspectiveRisk Analysis, 1997
- Comparison of multi-media transport and transformation models: Regional Fugacity model vs. CalTOXChemosphere, 1995
- A global distribution model for persistent organic chemicalsScience of The Total Environment, 1995
- A proposal for the classification of toxic substances within the framework of life cycle assessment of productsChemosphere, 1993