Capital Constructions: Newspaper Reporting in Death Penalty Cases
Authors:
- 30 November 2004
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Analyses of Social Issues and Public Policy
- Vol. 4 (1) , 129-150
Abstract
This study evaluates aspects of newspaper reporting about death penalty cases and capital defendants. In a content analysis of newspaper coverage of a representative sample of 26 death penalty‐eligible defendants who were brought to trial in California, we found that articles tended to cite primarily from law enforcement and prosecutorial sources, focused very heavily on the characteristics of the crime, and omitted or de‐emphasized most other aspects of the case. News coverage generally failed to place the criminal behavior of the defendant in any social historical or contextual framework from which readers (as potential voters and jurors) could grasp the potential mitigating elements of the case. We conclude that newspaper coverage of capital crimes may influence public support for the death penalty, and undermine public appreciation of the role of social contextual factors in crime causation in general. It also may bias the perspective with which potential jurors approach specific capital trials and even contribute to the lack of instructional comprehension that has been found to plague the death sentencing process.Keywords
This publication has 30 references indexed in Scilit:
- Clarifying life and death matters: An analysis of instructional comprehension and penalty phase closing arguments.Law and Human Behavior, 1997
- A journey into the unknown: Pretrial publicity and capital casesCommunication Law and Policy, 1996
- Comprehensibility of approved jury instructions in capital murder cases.Journal of Applied Psychology, 1995
- Public information officers: A descriptive study of crime news gatekeepersJournal of Criminal Justice, 1995
- Comprehending life and death matters: A preliminary study of California's capital penalty instructions.Law and Human Behavior, 1994
- News media influences on public views of sentencing.Law and Human Behavior, 1990
- Media effects on jurors.Law and Human Behavior, 1990
- “Join Our War”: The Construction of Ideology in a Newspaper Crimefighting CampaignCrime & Delinquency, 1989
- Public support for the death penalty: Retribution as just deserts or retribution as revenge?Justice Quarterly, 1988
- Free press and fair trial: The role of behavioral research.Law and Human Behavior, 1986