The burden of COVID-19 on health systems and health-care workers has been substantial worldwide. The outbreak exposed health-care personnel to chronic stress, uncertainty, and trauma. This study examined health-care workers’ COVID-19 experiences and reactions in the United States and Poland using data from an online survey (n = 139) conducted in the summer of 2020. The participants were predominantly female nursing professionals; 32% were physicians. In contrast with Poles, US health-care professionals reported stronger perceptions of health system being overwhelmed and lacking supplies, higher levels of coronavirus threat, more protective behaviors, and higher levels of psychological impacts. However, Polish health-care workers reported higher financial impacts of the pandemic, likely associated with the Polish national health system being underfunded and the inadequate compensation of health-care workers. The findings extend the knowledge of cross-cultural variations in health-care workers’ experiences and impacts during the COVID-19 pandemic.