Direct Nucleation Control with External Heating Loop: Process System Engineering, Simulation and Experimental Investigation
Open Access
Abstract
The aim of this work was to explore and test the concept of a novel direct nucleation control method with external dissolution of fine crystals (E-DNC). It was postulated that the heating cycles of the internal DNC method could be transferred from the crystallizer jacket to an electrically heated recirculation tube, thereby using less energy and requiring a shorter time compared to internal DNC. The conceptual model was explored and developed by reviewing previous research on the topic and addressing known drawbacks. Engineering experience and a heuristic approach led to the conclusion that five commonly used controllers would suffice for a straightforward implementation of the method. A simplified simulation was developed to compare the time and energy requirements for the internal and external DNC methods, and it was concluded that external DNC uses 37% less energy and 19% less time compared to internal DNC. The laboratory system was then constructed by modifying the internal DNC apparatus with inexpensive and commonly used components. A linear cooling experiment was performed to establish the baseline for comparison with E-DNC experiments and to set the expected count range. The E-DNC experiments were then conducted with the aim of obtaining larger crystal sizes, and it was shown that the process could be designed in only three experiments. Adjusting the heating rate and count limit led to a significant increase in median crystal size (22.5%) compared to linear cooling.Keywords
Funding Information
- European Union’s NextGenerationEU
This publication has 39 references indexed in Scilit:
- Particle-Size-Determined Crystallization and Dissolution Behavior of Amorphous GriseofulvinPharmaceutical Research, 2025
- Modernizing non-classical protein crystallization through industry 4.0: Advanced monitoring and modelling utilizing process analytical technologyChemical Engineering Research and Design, 2024
- Diastereomer salt crystallization: Comprehensive process modeling and DoE-driven comparison of custom-coded and user-friendly simulatorsChemical Engineering Journal, 2023
- Enabling technologies for process intensification in pharmaceutical research and manufacturingCurrent Opinion in Chemical Engineering, 2023
- A synthetic machine learning framework for complex crystallization processes: The case study of the second-order asymmetric transformation of enantiomersChemical Engineering Journal, 2023
- External fine particle removal for crystallization processes: Introduction and systematic comparison with the temperature cycling-based fines removalChemical Engineering and Processing - Process Intensification, 2022
- Strategic evaluation of different direct nucleation control approaches for controlling batch cooling crystallisation via simulation and experimental case studiesComputers & Chemical Engineering, 2019
- Temperature setpoint-ramp control structure for batch reactorsChemical Engineering Science, 2019
- Process intensification for pharmaceutical crystallizationChemical Engineering and Processing - Process Intensification, 2018
- Analysis of the efficacy, safety, and regulatory status of novel forms of creatineAmino Acids, 2011