Comparing and Extending the Use of Defeasible Argumentation with Quantitative Data in Real-World Contexts
Preprint
- 1 January 2022
- preprint
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Abstract
Dealing with uncertain, contradicting, and ambiguous information is still a central issue in Artificial Intelligence (AI). As a result, many formalisms have been proposed or adapted so as to consider non-monotonicity. A non-monotonic formalism is one that allows the retraction of previous conclusions or claims, from premises, in light of new evidence, offering some desirable flexibility when dealing with uncertainty. Among possible options, knowledge-base, non-monotonic reasoning approaches have seen their use being increased in practice. Nonetheless, only a limited number of works and researchers have performed any sort of comparison among them. This research article focuses on evaluating the inferential capacity of defeasible argumentation, a formalism particularly envisioned for modelling non-monotonic reasoning. In addition to this, fuzzy reasoning and expert systems, extended for handling non-monotonicity of reasoning, are selected and employed as baselines, due to their vast and accepted use within the AI community. Computational trust was selected as the domain of application of such models. Trust is an ill-defined construct, hence, reasoning applied to the inference of trust can be seen as non-monotonic. Inference models were designed to assign trust scalars to editors of the Wikipedia project. Scalars assigned to recognized trustworthy editors provided the basis for the analysis of the models’ inferential capacity according to evaluation metrics from the domain of computational trust. In particular, argument-based models demonstrated more robustness than those built upon the baselines despite the knowledge bases or datasets employed. This study contributes to the body ofknowledge through the exploitation of defeasible argumentation and its comparison to similar approaches. It adds to previous works, empirically enhancing the generalisability of defeasible argumentation as a compelling approach to reason with quantitative data and uncertain knowledge.Keywords
This publication has 71 references indexed in Scilit:
- An Investigation of Argumentation Theory for the Prediction of Survival in Elderly Using Biomarkers2018
- Argumentation for Knowledge Representation, Conflict Resolution, Defeasible Inference and Its Integration with Machine Learning2016
- Modeling Mental Workload Via Rule-Based Expert System: A Comparison with NASA-TLX and Workload Profile2016
- On Supported Inference and Extension Selection in Abstract Argumentation Frameworks2015
- Argument Ranking with Categoriser FunctionLecture Notes in Computer Science, 2014
- Modeling user reputation in wikisStatistical Analysis and Data Mining: An ASA Data Science Journal, 2010
- Coalitions of arguments: A tool for handling bipolar argumentation frameworksInternational Journal of Intelligent Systems, 2009
- On bipolarity in argumentation frameworksInternational Journal of Intelligent Systems, 2008
- On the Acceptability of Arguments in Bipolar Argumentation Frameworks2005
- The Role of Logic in Computational Models of Legal Argument: A Critical Survey2002