Temporal and Contextual Variations in Job Satisfaction Between Physicians and Nurses: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
Authors:
- Nazerke NarymbayevaNNNazerke Narymbayeva
- Maksut KamalievMKMaksut Kamaliev
- Konrad Tomasz JuszkiewiczKJKonrad Tomasz Juszkiewicz
- Kuralay KanafyanovaKKKuralay Kanafyanova
- Sholpan AliyevaSASholpan Aliyeva
- Nadira AitambayevaNANadira Aitambayeva
- Laila NazarovaLaila Nazarova
- Sharapat MoiynbayevaSMSharapat Moiynbayeva
- Akylbek SaktapovASAkylbek Saktapov
- Shnara SvetlanovaShnara Svetlanova
Open Access
- 21 November 2025
- journal article
- review article
- Published by MDPI AG in Healthcare
- Vol. 13 (23) , 3008
Abstract
Objectives: This systematic review and meta-analysis evaluated differences in job satisfaction scores between nurses and physicians, examining variation by (a) care setting (hospital, emergency department, outpatient, mixed), and (b) time period (pre-COVID, during COVID, post-COVID). Methods: We systematically searched PubMed, Scopus, ScienceDirect, Web of Science, and CINAHL for studies published between January 2020 and July 2025. Eligible studies reported mean and standard deviation values for job satisfaction among physicians and nurses in healthcare settings across the specified timeframes. Studies were excluded if they assessed other types of satisfaction or combined data across COVID periods. Pooled standardized mean difference (SMD) was calculated using random-effects models in R. Results: Before COVID-19, the SMD was −2.40 (95% CI −8.05 to 3.26; I2 = 98%). During the pandemic, the estimate was 1.39 (95% CI −0.57 to 3.35; I2 = 91.5%), and post-pandemic, it remained small (SMD = 0.29; 95% CI −1.63 to 2.22; I2 = 95.8%). Emergency care during COVID showed a significant advantage for physicians (SMD = 0.29; 95% CI 0.05 to 0.52; I2 = 0%). Post-COVID, mixed settings slightly favored physicians (SMD = 0.06), while primary care favored nurses (SMD = −0.30); subgroup differences were significant. Conclusions: The findings reveal that job satisfaction is not solely determined by professional role but is significantly influenced by temporal and contextual factors. Job satisfaction is shaped more by temporal and contextual factors than by professional role. While no consistent differences were observed pre-pandemic, emergency care favored physicians during COVID, and post-pandemic trends showed modest advantages for nurses in primary care and physicians in mixed settings. Due to the methodological limitations of this meta-analysis, including high heterogeneity, reliance on cross-sectional data, and very low/low certainty of evidence, these results should be interpreted with caution.Keywords
This publication has 70 references indexed in Scilit:
- Strengthening resilience and patient safety in healthcare institutions during the COVID-19 pandemic: Experience from a quasi-medical centerJournal of the Formosan Medical Association, 2024
- The relationship between telemedicine tools and physician satisfaction, quality of care, and patient visits during the COVID-19 pandemicInternational Journal of Medical Informatics, 2024
- Job satisfaction of primary healthcare professionals (public sector): A cross-sectional study in MoroccoHeliyon, 2023
- Research Note: Interpreting findings of a systematic review using GRADE methodsJournal of Physiotherapy, 2023
- Covid-19 pandemic induced traumatizing medical job contents and mental health distortions of physicians working in private practices and in hospitalsScientific Reports, 2023
- Physician and Nurse Practitioner Teamwork and Job Satisfaction: Gender and ProfessionThe Journal for Nurse Practitioners, 2022
- Meta‐analysis of prevalence: I2 statistic and how to deal with heterogeneityResearch Synthesis Methods, 2022
- Measuring the safety climate in an Australian emergency departmentInternational Emergency Nursing, 2021
- Job satisfaction among physicians and nurses involved in the management of multiple sclerosis: the role of happiness and meaning at workNeurological Sciences, 2021
- The Effect of Nurse‐Physician Collaboration on Job Satisfaction, Team Commitment, and Turnover Intention in NursesResearch in Nursing & Health, 2016