Exclusive versus everyday forms of professional knowledge: legitimacy claims in conventional and alternative medicine
Open Access
- 1 July 2006
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Sociology of Health & Illness
- Vol. 28 (5) , 533-557
Abstract
In this paper I present a model of professional knowledge forms that accounts for the different, and sometimes contradictory, ways in which medical doctors (MDs) and various complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) practitioners define their competencies and make legitimacy claims. The first section provides a schema for problematising knowledge and its relationship to legitimacy by distinguishing between the context, form and content of professional knowledge. I draw particularly upon Jamous and Peloille's (1970 ) distinction between the technical or indeterminate forms of professional knowledge. I argue that their characterisation might be enriched by attending to dimensions of ‘exclusive’ versus ‘everyday’ knowledge forms. In particular, I point out that both technical and indeterminate forms are amenable to exclusion, or conversely can be made accessible as everyday knowledge. Both forms can thus be employed in attempts to legitimate professional practice. In the final section, I map the current context of CAM and biomedicine onto this expanded professional knowledge map.Keywords
This publication has 30 references indexed in Scilit:
- Moving forward? Complementary and alternative practitioners seeking self‐regulationSociology of Health & Illness, 2004
- Alternative Medicine and the Health Care Division of Labour: Present Trends and Future ProspectsCurrent Sociology, 2001
- General practitioners, complementary therapies and evidence-based medicine: the defence of clinical autonomyComplementary Therapies in Medicine, 2000
- Decline vs. retention of medical power through restratification: an examination of the Ontario caseSociology of Health & Illness, 1997
- Alternative medicine in the United StatesSocial Science & Medicine, 1994
- The Sociology of Work and OccupationsAnnual Review of Sociology, 1993
- Contextualizing Alternative Medicine: The Exotic, the Marginal and the Perfectly MundaneAnthropology Today, 1993
- Limits to medical dominance: The case of chiropracticSocial Science & Medicine, 1986
- Knowledge Mandates: Collective Influence by Scientific, Normative and Syncretic ProfessionsThe British Journal of Sociology, 1985
- Professionalism: Rise and FallInternational Journal of Health Services, 1979