Consent and Autonomy in the Genomics Era
Open Access
- 2 May 2019
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Current Genetic Medicine Reports
- Vol. 7 (2) , 85-91
Abstract
Purpose of Review Genomic tests offer increased opportunity for diagnosis, but their outputs are often uncertain and complex; results may need to be revised and/or may not be relevant until some future time. We discuss the challenges that this presents for consent and autonomy. Recent Findings Popular discourse around genomic testing tends to be strongly deterministic and optimistic, yet many findings from genomic tests are uncertain or unclear. Clinical conversations need to anticipate and potentially challenge unrealistic expectations of what a genomic test can deliver in order to enhance autonomy and ensure that consent to genomic testing is valid. Summary We conclude that ‘fully informed’ consent is often not possible in the context of genomic testing, but that an open-ended approach is appropriate. We consider that such broad consent can only work if located within systems or organisations that are trustworthy and that have measures in place to ensure that such open-ended agreements are not abused. We suggest that a relational concept of autonomy has benefits in encouraging focus on the networks and relationships that allow decision making to flourish.Keywords
Funding Information
- Wellcome Trust (208053/Z/17/Z)
This publication has 37 references indexed in Scilit:
- Exceptions to the rule: Case studies in the prediction of pathogenicity for genetic variants in hereditary cancer genesClinical Genetics, 2015
- Attitudes of parents toward the return of targeted and incidental genomic research findings in childrenGenetics in Medicine, 2014
- “I want to know what's in Pandora's box”: Comparing stakeholder perspectives on incidental findings in clinical whole genomic sequencingAmerican Journal of Medical Genetics Part A, 2012
- “What does it mean?”: Uncertainties in understanding results of chromosomal microarray testingGenetics in Medicine, 2012
- Can Broad Consent be Informed Consent?Public Health Ethics, 2011
- Feedback of individual genetic results to research participants: in favor of a qualified disclosure policyHuman Mutation, 2011
- On Jim Watson's APOE status: genetic information is hard to hideEuropean Journal of Human Genetics, 2008
- Distinct Clinical Features of Paraganglioma Syndromes Associated With SDHB and SDHD Gene MutationsJAMA, 2004
- Genetic information: a joint account?BMJ, 2004
- Understanding Autonomy Relationally: Toward a Reconfiguration of Bioethical PrinciplesThe Journal of Medicine and Philosophy: A Forum for Bioethics and Philosophy of Medicine, 2001