Symmetrical twins: On the relationship between Actor-Network theory and the sociology of critical capacities
Authors:
- 26 April 2012
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in European Journal of Social Theory
- Vol. 15 (2) , 157-178
Abstract
This article explores the elective affinities between Actor-Network Theory (ANT) and the sociology of critical capacities. It argues that these two research programmes can be understood as symmetrical twins. We show the extent to which the exchange between Bruno Latour and Luc Boltanski has influenced their respective theoretical developments. Three strong encounters between the twin research programmes may be distinguished. The first encounter concerns explanations for social change. The second encounter focuses on the status of objects and their relationship to places. The third encounter is about the concept of critique. Drawing on their long-term mutual readings, we gain insight into how pleas for symmetrical analysis raised in response to Bourdieu’s theory of fields have evolved within both ANT and the sociology of critical capacity. We conclude by relating the development of the respective research programmes to the issue of disciplinary boundaries.Keywords
This publication has 30 references indexed in Scilit:
- Laboratizing and de-laboratizing the worldHistory of the Human Sciences, 2012
- Pragmatic Sociology as Cultural SociologyEuropean Journal of Social Theory, 2003
- Nécessité et justificationRevue économique, 2002
- Forms of valuing nature: arguments and modes of justification in French and American environmental disputes2000
- After JustificationEuropean Journal of Social Theory, 1999
- The economic consequences of Bruno LatourSocial Epistemology, 1996
- Was the Last Turn The Right Turn? The Semiotic Turn and A. J. GreimasConfigurations, 1994
- Review Article: Action as a Combination of ‘Common Worlds’The Sociological Review, 1993
- Science Studies in France: A Sociological ViewSocial Studies of Science, 1990
- Sociologie critique et sociologie de la critiquePolitix, 1990