Multi‐Center, Multi‐Vendor Validation of Simultaneous MRI‐Based Proton Density Fat Fraction and R2* Mapping Using a Combined Proton Density Fat Fraction‐R2* Phantom
Authors:
- Jitka StarekovaJSJitka Starekova
- David RutkowskiDRDavid Rutkowski
- Won C. BaeWBWon C. Bae
- Hung DoHDHung Do
- Ananth J. MadhuranthakamAMAnanth J. Madhuranthakam
- Vadim MalisVMVadim Malis
- Sheng Qing LinSLSheng Qing Lin
- Suraj SeraiSSSuraj Serai
- Takeshi YokooTYTakeshi Yokoo
- Scott B. ReederSRScott B. Reeder
- Diego HernandoDHDiego Hernando
Open Access
- 18 April 2025
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Magnetic Resonance Imaging
- Vol. 62 (3) , 800-811
Abstract
Background: Fat and iron deposition confound measurements of R2* and proton density fat fraction (PDFF), respectively, yet their combined impact on reproducibility is poorly understood.Purpose: To evaluate the multi‐center, multi‐vendor reproducibility of PDFF and R2* quantification using a PDFF‐R2* phantom.Study Type: Prospective multi‐center, phantom study.Phantom: Commercial PDFF‐R2* phantom with simultaneously controlled combination of PDFF (0%–30%) and R2* (50–600 s−1) values.Field Strength/Sequence: 1.5‐T and 3‐T, three‐dimensional (3D) multi‐echo, spoiled‐gradient‐echo sequences, in four different centers, each with a different vendor.Assessment: Two acquisition protocols were used, optimized for moderate R2* (Protocol 1) and high R2* (Protocol 2), respectively. The phantom was imaged multiple times at one of the centers to assess its stability.Statistical Tests: Intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC), linear regression analysis, reproducibility coefficient (RDC) and repeatability coefficient (RC).Results: Excellent agreement was observed for PDFF measurements between centers, vendors, field strengths, and protocols (ICC = 0.97). Stratified by protocol, excellent agreement was observed, with ICC = 0.96 (RDC = 6.2%) for Protocol 1 and ICC = 0.99 (RDC = 3.8%) for Protocol 2. Increased variability in PDFF measurements was observed with increasing PDFF and especially with higher R2*. Excellent agreement was observed for R2* between centers, vendors, field strengths, and protocols (ICC = 0.99). Stratified by protocol, strong agreement was observed, with ICC = 0.988 (RDC = 66.7 s−1) for Protocol 1 and ICC = 0.99 (RDC = 57.7 s−1) for Protocol 2. Higher variability in R2* measurements was observed in vials with higher PDFF or R2*. Stability tests demonstrated an ICC = 1.0 for PDFF and R2*, and RC of 0.4% for PDFF and 12 s−1 for R2*.Data Conclusion: Excellent PDFF and R2* reproducibility was observed across centers, vendors, field strengths, and acquisition protocols. Reproducibility decreased slightly with increasing PDFF and R2*, especially for PDFF measurements in vials with high R2*.Evidence Level: N/A.Technical Efficacy: Stage 1.Keywords
Funding Information
- National Institute of Health Sciences (R01 EB031886, R01CA283663)
- Small Business Innovation Research (R44EB025729)
- Cancer Prevention and Research Institute of Texas (RP190049)
This publication has 30 references indexed in Scilit:
- Iron overload disordersHepatology Communications, 2022
- Limits of Fat Quantification in the Presence of Iron OverloadJournal of Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 2021
- Long-term inter-platform reproducibility, bias, and linearity of commercial PDFF MRI methods for fat quantification: a multi-center, multi-vendor phantom studyEuropean Radiology, 2021
- Temperature‐corrected proton density fat fraction estimation using chemical shift‐encoded MRI in phantomsMagnetic Resonance in Medicine, 2021
- Complex confounder-corrected R2* mapping for liver iron quantification with MRIEuropean Radiology, 2020
- Design and evaluation of quantitative MRI phantoms to mimic the simultaneous presence of fat, iron, and fibrosis in the liverMagnetic Resonance in Medicine, 2020
- Multisite, multivendor validation of the accuracy and reproducibility of proton-density fat-fraction quantification at 1.5T and 3T using a fat-water phantomMagnetic Resonance in Medicine, 2016
- Quantification of liver iron with MRI: State of the art and remaining challengesJournal of Magnetic Resonance Imaging, 2014
- On the confounding effect of temperature on chemical shift‐encoded fat quantificationMagnetic Resonance in Medicine, 2013
- Multipeak fat‐corrected complex R2* relaxometry: Theory, optimization, and clinical validationMagnetic Resonance in Medicine, 2013