Geographic Targeting and Normative Frames: Revisiting the Equity of Conditional Cash Transfer Program Distribution in Bolivia, Colombia, Ecuador, and Peru
Open Access
- 31 July 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in International Journal for Equity in Health
- Vol. 19 (1) , 1-12
Abstract
Background: Four Andean countries of Bolivia, Colombia, Ecuador, and Peru introduced national health-focused conditional cash transfer (CCT) programs in the 2000s. This study probes whether policymakers in these countries targeted CCT programs to subregions with the highest prevalence of ill-health or those with the lowest socioeconomic status (SES) to evaluate the equity of geographic targeting and means-testing, as well as the potential role of normative frames, bounded rationality, and clientelism as explanatory mechanisms for inequities in social spending.Methods: The distribution of vaccination coverage, underweight, stunting, and child deaths is established both within and between subnational regions and SES quintiles from 1998 to 2012 using every available nationally representative household survey. The equity of CCT program targeting and strength of association with subregional SES and health outcomes are measured using generalized entropy index decomposition and meta-regression. Finally, simple predictive models for CCT targeting are created using lagged subregional SES, health outcomes, and concentration indices.Results: Bolivia and Peru both effectively targeted at-risk subregions, but subregions in Peru with no CCT program coverage result in higher mistargeting rates for the country as a whole. Only Bolivia failed to attain CCT coverage concentration indices that are at least as large as the health inequalities they are targeting. Despite this insufficient progressivity, Bolivia has the most efficient subregional targeting, while the lowest rates of mistargeting for child deaths are found in Colombia and Ecuador. Finally, the simple predictive model performs as well or better than observed CCT coverage distribution for every country, year, and outcome.Conclusions: Both Peru and Ecuador have targeted programs to their poorest populations effectively, demonstrating that this is possible with both universal and geographic targeting. No clear evidence of clientelism was found, while the dominant normative frame underlying CCT program targeting decisions appears to be the relative SES of subregions, rather than absolute SES, prevalence of health outcomes, or health inequalities. To reduce the inequitable impacts of bounded rationality, policymakers can use simple predictive models to target CCT coverage effectively and without leaving behind the most vulnerable populations that happen to live in more affluent subregions.Keywords
This publication has 37 references indexed in Scilit:
- Demographic and health surveys: a profileInternational Journal of Epidemiology, 2012
- Conditional Cash Transfer Programmes: The Recent Experience in Latin America and the CaribbeanSSRN Electronic Journal, 2011
- Effect of Ecuador’s cash transfer program (Bono de Desarrollo Humano) on child development in infants and toddlers: A randomized effectiveness trialSocial Science & Medicine, 2011
- Models of Clientelism and Policy Change: The Case of Conditional Cash Transfer Programmes in Mexico and BrazilBulletin of Latin American Research, 2011
- Conditional Cash Transfer Programs: Achievements and IllusionsGlobal Social Policy, 2009
- Welfare States in Developing Countries: Unique or Universal?The Journal of Politics, 2007
- On the interpretation of a concentration index of inequalityHealth Economics, 2004
- Beyond the income inequality hypothesis: class, neo-liberalism, and health inequalitiesSocial Science & Medicine, 2004
- Ideas, Politics, and Public PolicyAnnual Review of Sociology, 2002
- Inequality Decomposition by Factor ComponentsEconometrica, 1982