This policy paper examines the advances and limitations of the Special Jurisdiction for Peace’s (JEP) efforts to recognise fighters who were victims of gender-based violence (GBV) within armed groups, a form of violence often overlooked by transitional justice mechanisms worldwide. While grounded in the Colombian context, the lessons emerging from this experience offer valuable insights for other conflict and post-conflict settings, particularly for judges, legislators, international actors, and policymakers working on human rights and transitional justice. The paper draws on findings from: (i) A roundtable held in Bogotá (Colombia) on 15 July 2025 with legal representatives of victims, women’s organisations, and JEP officials, organised in collaboration with Universidad del Rosario; (ii) Twenty-three semi-structured interviews conducted in Bogotá (Colombia) between March and May 2025 with legal representatives of victims, women’s and LGBTQ+ organisations, JEP and Truth Commission officials, academics, and transitional justice experts; and (iii) in depth documentary and case law research. The policy paper is an output of the project The Subversive Victim: Victimhood, Agency & Sexual and Gender-based Violence in Colombian Non-State Armed Groups, carried out at Queen’s University Belfast School of Law and funded by the ESRC-NINE DTP Postdoctoral Fellowship. The study examines how the notion of the “ideal victim” shapes the recognition of GBV against fighters within Colombia’s transitional justice system, revealing both the limitations of existing legal frameworks and the potential of bottom-up approaches to construct more intersectional and complex narratives of victimhood.