Evaluating the Youth Criminal Justice Act after Five Years: A Qualified Success
Authors:
- 1 April 2009
- journal article
- Published by University of Toronto Press Inc. (UTPress) in Canadian Journal of Criminology and Criminal Justice
- Vol. 51 (2) , 131-167
Abstract
The Youth Criminal Justice Act (2003) was enacted with the intent of decreasing the use of courts and restricting the use of custody for adolescent offenders, while improving the effectiveness of the responses to serious violent youth offenders. This paper assesses the impact of the act in its first five years. It reviews salient provisions of the act dealing with sentencing and diversion, discusses Supreme Court of Canada jurisprudence interpreting the act, and presents statistical data on the impact of the YCJA on diversion and sentencing of youth and on youth court and custodial caseloads. The Supreme Court has narrowly interpreted the provisions of the YCJA that allow for the use of custody, contributing to a reduction in use of custody. The Court has also emphasized that youth are to be treated differently from adults and ruled unconstitutional provisions of the YCJA that created a presumption of adult sentencing for the most serious offences by young offenders, limiting the effect of provisions of the act directed at serious violent offenders. The YCJA has succeeded in significantly reducing the rates of use of court and custody, without increasing recorded youth crime. There continue to be significant regional variations in rates of use of youth courts and custody. Although regional differences in the use of court have declined under the YCJA, variation in the use of custody has not been significantly affected by the new act. Youth crime remains a contentious political concern in Canada.Keywords
This publication has 9 references indexed in Scilit:
- Youth Crime Rates and the Youth Justice SystemCanadian Journal of Criminology and Criminal Justice, 2008
- Structuring Police DiscretionCriminal Justice Policy Review, 2008
- Youth Justice?European Journal of Criminology, 2007
- Backlist: Little AlleluiasAmerican Book Review, 2006
- Young Offenders in Custody: Risk and AdjustmentCriminal Justice and Behavior, 2005
- Understanding Sentencing under the Youth Criminal Justice ActAlberta Law Review, 2003
- Diversion, Conferencing, and Extrajudicial Measures for Adolescent OffendersAlberta Law Review, 2003
- Trends in youth crime in Canada, 1977-1996Canadian Journal of Criminology, 1999
- Juvenile Justice & Youth Violence1997