Benchmarking saliency methods for chest X-ray interpretation
Preprint
Abstract
Saliency methods, which “explain” deep neural networks by producing heat maps that highlight the areas of the medical image that influence model prediction, are often presented to clinicians as an aid in diagnostic decision-making. Although many saliency methods have been proposed for medical imaging interpretation, rigorous investigation of the accuracy and reliability of these strategies is necessary before they are integrated into the clinical setting. In this work, we quantitatively evaluate seven saliency methods—including Grad-CAM, Grad-CAM++, and Integrated Gradients—across multiple neural network architectures using two evaluation metrics. We establish the first human benchmark for chest X-ray segmentation in a multilabel classification set up, and examine under what clinical conditions saliency maps might be more prone to failure in localizing important pathologies compared to a human expert benchmark. We find that (i) while Grad-CAM generally localized pathologies better than the other evaluated saliency methods, all seven performed significantly worse compared with the human benchmark; (ii) the gap in localization performance between Grad-CAM and the human benchmark was largest for pathologies that were smaller in size and had shapes that were more complex; (iii) model confidence was positively correlated with Grad-CAM localization performance. While it is difficult to know whether poor localization performance is attributable to the model or to the saliency method, our work demonstrates that several important limitations of saliency methods must be addressed before we can rely on them for deep learning explainability in medical imaging.Keywords
All Related Versions
- Published version: Nature Machine Intelligence, 4 (10), 867.
This publication has 39 references indexed in Scilit:
- A survey on deep learning in medical image analysisMedical Image Analysis, 2017
- ChestX-Ray8: Hospital-Scale Chest X-Ray Database and Benchmarks on Weakly-Supervised Classification and Localization of Common Thorax Diseases2017
- Deep Residual Learning for Image Recognition2016
- On Pixel-Wise Explanations for Non-Linear Classifier Decisions by Layer-Wise Relevance PropagationPLOS ONE, 2015
- Going deeper with convolutions2015
- Visualizing and Understanding Convolutional Networks2014
- Interobserver Reliability of the Chest Radiograph in Community-Acquired PneumoniaChest, 1996
- Interobserver Variability in the Radiographic Diagnosis of Adult Outpatient PneumoniaActa Radiologica, 1992
- A Threshold Selection Method from Gray-Level HistogramsIEEE Transactions on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics, 1979
- Disagreements in Chest Roentgen InterpretationChest, 1975